[Revisited]Weekly Poll: Favorite mewithoutYou Album

Figured I'd throw the EP on here since its been out a minute.

 

CUFTF is my personal favorite. I recognize that it's not their best, but it's the one that stuck most for me and was the first album I heard from them.

 

Brother, Sister with Pale Horses as a very close second

 

This is honestly the hardest one for me. I think that Pale Horses, Ten Stories, and Brother, Sister are all on equal footing. I love them all sooooo so much.

I think Brother, Sister edges them out because seeing it played straight through was one of the best concert experiences of my life.

 

Really really hope whoever voted for the EP talks about it in here.

 

for the past 12 years, up until literally a couple of weeks ago, my answer would be brother, sister. lately i just cannot get enough of pale horses and i truly think it's my favorite.

 

Brother, Sister will always be my favourite cause it was my first and means so much to me on a personal level. But most days I'd put it and Ten Stories on equal footing.

 

CFUTF, Ten Stories and Pale Horses are all fantastic.

That said, Brother, Sister is easily their best imo.

 

Brother Sister then pale horses then it’s all crazy


But the new album is favorite one ever

 

Brother, Sister, Catch For Us The Foxes & Pale Horses are three of my favourite albums. Hard to decide.

 

*shrieks like an excited schoolgirl*

 

Its only been a few hours, but I didn't think B,S would be this huge. Thought it'd be Catch by a lot.

 

Pale Horses is my favorite but Brother, Sister is going to win and I'm not too mad haha.

 

I can't do this

 

I spoke to you before mwY's set in Birmingham 2 years ago because I saw you on AP! Still upset I missed Delta Sleep's set though...

 

that was me. the EP is maybe my favorite thing i’ve heard all year

 

Bold! But I respect it, 'Cities of the Plain' is a top 10 track mwY for me!

 

I love all of my pups for different reasons.

 

I could answer a different album every day of the week and they'd each be a valid choice.

 

Catch, Brother, Pale are pretty much tied for #1 in my mind, but gun to my head, I voted Brother.

 

Maybe @Dog Fish can fill in

 

Fuck you, James

 

The answer to this question changes constantly. Today the answer is Ten Stories. I've listened to it like 15 times this week.

 

I think it’s their best music

 

I’m with ya