Relient K Band • Page 52

Savanna. It's a great song and I'd argue that it is the 'heart' of FANSD as a whole...thematically and such

 

(If you want it)

To be honest, the band chose to split the record how they chose to split the record... that means this is a 'full' song. I just listened to the two finalists. It works by itself. I'm going with it!

Savannah is a great song but there are a few that went out that I would have voted above it (Candlelight, Therapy, Sahara, If You Believe Me, This Is The End). Still can't believe If You Believe Me went out so early to a honest!

 

Savannah takes the cake.

 

I'll pick Savannah just because (If You Want It) doesn't feel complete to me by itself.

 

(If You Want It)

 

(If You Want It)

 

Lunchtime current score.

Savannah (6)
(If You Want It) (4)

 

So, I'll be ending this round around 9pm est and starting the Nashville EP. How does everyone like the round being open the full 24 hours? Everyone having time to vote? Is it too slow now? Let me know!

 

It has worked better for me in terms of voting in every round but I'll go with the majority.

 

It’s better.

 

Well, that's it. Savannah moves on to the champ bracket and If you Want It prepares for the runner up bracket.

Nashville EP up shortly.

 

Alright everyone, welcome to the RELIENT K FACE OFF. This will be NCAA style matches, with randomly generated brackets for each album facing off to decide which is the winner of each album. At the end of all of the albums, we'll do a finale Champions Bracket to decide the best overall Relient K song. We will start off with Air For Free and work our way backwards.

Due to the band's insane amount of B-sides, I may just do them as their own album, and just use the B sides from The Bird and The B Sides. Anyone against that? Any songs this would leave out that would ruin anyone's day? If so, let me know and I'll include a couple with some normal albums.
Update on B-sides: I decided to throw some random B-sides into the Bird and the Bee Sides bracket. So if you don't see a Bside with an album it should be there down the road.

Here are the rules:

1. Voting will take place over 10-24 hour period, depending on how close the matches are (if there's a wide margin too far to beat, the round may be run ruled to not waste time).
2. You must vote on every match in a round. If you don't your other votes don't count. Just reply to this thread with your choices. I will not vote unless there is a tie needed to be broken.
3. Feel free to discuss why you chose one song over the other and why you like that song. It's what helps keeps these fun!
4. I avoid byes into rounds if I can, but sometimes it's necessary. These are randomly generated I do not pick them.
5. Once your votes are counted, signified by me 'liking' your post, there are no vote changes. Choose wisely before posting!

And with that, let's begin...

The Nashville EP FACE OFF
--------------------------
Round 1

The Scene and Herd vs. Bee Your Man

There Was No Thief vs. You'll Always Be My Best Friend

There Was Another Time In My Life vs. Where Do I Go From Here?

Curl Up and Die vs. I Just Want You To Know

The Last, The Lost, The Least, vs. At Least We Made It This Far

---------------------------
Round 2

Beaming vs. Winner #1

Winner #2 vs. Winner #3

The Lining Is Silver vs Winner #4

No Reaction vs. Winner #5

---------------------------
Round 1 is now open! Go, go, go!

 

The Scene and Herd

There Was No Thief

Where Do I Go From Here?

Curl Up and Die

At Least We Made It This Far

 

The Scene and Herd

You'll Always Be My Best Friend

Where Do I Go from Here?

I Just want You to Know (this one was hard)

At Least We Made it This Far

 

The Last, the Lost, the Least brings back awesome Ace Troubleshooter memories, but it can't compare with At Least

 

The Scene and Herd

There Was No Thief

There Was Another Time in My Life

Curl Up and Die

At Least We Made It This Far

 

The Scene and Herd
You'll Always Be My Best Friend
Where Do I Go From Here?
Curl Up and Die
The Last, The Lost, The Least

 

The Scene and Herd
There Was No Thief
Where Do I Go From Here?
Curl Up and Die
At Least We Made It This Far

 

Where are at this morning...

The Scene and Herd (5)
Bee Your Man (0)

There Was No Thief (3)
You'll Always Be My Best Friend (2)

There Was Another Time In My Life (1)
Where Do I Go From Here? (4)

Curl Up and Die (4)
I Just Want You To Know (1)

The Last, The Lost, The Least (1)
At Least We Made It This Far (4)

 

The Scene and Herd

There Was No Thief

There Was Another Time In My Life

Curl Up and Die

At Least We Made It This Far

 

So... turns out I've not really listened to this album enough to know song titles... and I'm away so can't update my iPod.

Only two I remember from song titles:

There was no thief
Curl up and die

I'm guessing that violates the rules, hah!

 

You must vote for each match for votes to count.

Either check the songs out (they are great) or just vote on song titles or the underdog song.

 

The Scene and Herd

There Was No Thief

Where Do I Go From Here?

Curl Up and Die

At Least We Made It This Far

 

Just made it in. 15 minutes or so to go.

 

Final results for Nashville EP Round 1

The Scene and Herd (7)
Bee Your Man (0)

There Was No Thief (5)
You'll Always Be My Best Friend (2)

There Was Another Time In My Life (2)
Where Do I Go From Here? (5)

Curl Up and Die (6)
I Just Want You To Know (1)

The Last, The Lost, The Least (1)
At Least We Made It This Far (6)

Round 2 begins shortly