PUP - Who Will Look After the Dogs? (May 2nd 2025) Album • Page 6

there are plenty of very good albums no one on this website ever discusses lol, seems narrowminded!

 

yeah then you just tell me to listen and sometimes I do and sometimes I don’t, spreadsheet boy

 

this is not true, because I would be posting about them

 

I am bummed that I’m not feeling these singles. Sad to say it’s the least excited I’ve been about a PUP album. Hoping these grow on me

 

I'm feeling the same as I did last album rollout which was negative but I ended up liking everything in context. Doesn't seem like they'll touch the first 3 albums on this one but I think I'll end up liking it still

 

I actually like these better than anything I can even remember from the last one, although I don’t think I like them quite as much as anything from Morbid Stuff.

 

I enjoy all of the PUP albums even the debut which I’ve recently found out people on this site do not enjoy.

 

Only so much bad you can say about an album that has Reservoir on it, I don't make the rules

Okay yes the other three clear it but STILL

 

People don’t like the debut? That’s crazy. One of the best debuts of a band in this scene…ever??

 

Yeah what? lol

 

Holds up super well, it's my least favourite PUP record but it still fucking goes

 

Oh thank god this drops this week. I was thinking it was june

 

Agree, it’s one of the debuts that feels the most “fully formed” of any band in this scene I can remember

 

Debut is probably my second favorite after TDIO

 

I think the debut is my favorite and very possibly their most consistent

 

love all their albums and enjoy the direction of these tunes but feels like Morbid Stuff will be their peak. love to be wrong!

 

My man.

 

The Dream is Over still reigns supreme for me, I mean... the 1-2 punch of Tour-DVP, Sleep in the Heat, PINE POINT, the list goes on... they were cookin' something special there

 

Morbid Stuff is my fav, but the dream is over is my next favorite

 

Morbid Stuff
PUP
The Dream Is Over
Unraveling

 

morbid stuff is easily their best, agreed the dream is over is next

 

Morbid Stuff
TDIO
UOPTB
PUP

 

I actually revisited The Unraveling recently and it’s a v good album. It’s like a perfect follow up to MS yet takes more swings.

 

i maintain robot love song is probably their best track but I don't really agree as a whole album