PUP - THE UNRAVELING OF PUPTHEBAND (April 1st, 2022) • Page 28

Discussion in 'Music Forum' started by soggytime, Jan 13, 2022.

  1. MexicanGuitars

    Chorus’ Expert on OTIP Track #8 Supporter

    Waiting because of those Single Mothers-esque verses is prob my favorite. The chorus vocal hook in Totally Fine is great too
     
    labourgeoisie and StatusAilments like this.
  2. jciswhatis

    Ugh, I hate America. Supporter

    Kill Something is the best song made for unraveling.
     
  3. imthegrimace

    Beat em off, Bucs! Supporter

    Been listening to em since yesterday. Not a bad song in the entire discography.
     
    bazzgod likes this.
  4. I think the debut is still my favorite.
     
  5. imthegrimace

    Beat em off, Bucs! Supporter

    Every album I listen to is my favorite at that moment
     
    Zilla and AFoolsGlory like this.
  6. StatusAilments

    Regular

    Either self-titled or TDIO are my favorites but everything they've done is solid. Digging the new song quite a bit
     
    imthegrimace likes this.
  7. rbsfeatures

    Regular

    Interesting there's so much diversity of opinions on it. for me TDIO is my favourite by a way, then Morbid Stuff second.
     
  8. waking season

    Trusted Prestigious

    Fuck it:

    Morbid Stuff
    PUP
    The Dream Is Over/The Unraveling of PUPTHEBAND

    They have a perfect discography so far though, EPs included
     
  9. imthegrimace

    Beat em off, Bucs! Supporter

    Just re listened to the debut and god damn what a perfect first album.
     
  10. HueyLewis

    Regular

    Feel like Unraveling really lacks the sing-a-long hooks that the earlier albums have.
     
    wisdomfordebris likes this.
  11. TomG

    Trusted Supporter

    Morbid Stuff
    PUP (has a band ever felt so fully formed on a debut??)
    The Dream Is Over
    Unraveling
     
  12. Kind of how I feel about this one, too
     
    jciswhatis likes this.
  13. rbsfeatures

    Regular

    agreed... not huge on the increased amount of talk-shouting vocals rather than singing, maybe the dream really was over
     
  14. imthegrimace

    Beat em off, Bucs! Supporter

    Shhhhh
     
  15. Yellowcard2006

    Trusted

  16. Very insightful read
     
  17. Carrow

    maybe this time, I won't be alright Supporter

    Kill Something absolutely belongs on the record and the interludes should have been taken out, as much as I love Unravelling (and FUCK YEAH the title track is one of yr best, guys) they maybe overextended themselves a bit.

    Album did give me the chance to see them for the first time though and I'll be forever grateful to it for that.
     
    labourgeoisie and jciswhatis like this.
  18. Yellowcard2006 Apr 4, 2026
    (Last edited: Apr 4, 2026)
    Yellowcard2006

    Trusted

    I feel good knowing Stefan hates the interludes as much as I do. Definitely should have been swapped with Kill Something.

    I enjoy this album but I can see why most fans would call it their worst. Something has to be last.
     
    Zilla and Carrow like this.
  19. Slampiece

    @haysanchez

    Filing for bankruptcy is easily my favorite Pup song, so it automatically makes this record not their worst for me. The self titled is probably my least favorite.
     
  20. imthegrimace

    Beat em off, Bucs! Supporter

    Cutting off the corners is one of their best songs
     
  21. i agree with most of that, totally fine and robot love song are incredible tracks
     
    fredwordsmith likes this.
  22. totally fine is one of their best songs

    he's too hard on relentless, that's one of my favorites. cutting off the corners as well. I like the record and I do listen to it a bunch, but I do like the feel of this based on what he wrote:

    Four Chords
    Totally Fine
    Robot Writes a Love song
    Relentless
    Waiting
    Cutting off the Corners
    PUPTHEBAND Inc. Is Filing for Bankruptcy

    throw in Matilda if you want, can't recall much about that song at the moment tbh.
     
    AFoolsGlory likes this.
  23. JRGComedy

    Prestigious Supporter

    I don’t really think this album is that far out of the realm of what they’ve always done haha
     
  24. jciswhatis

    Ugh, I hate America. Supporter

    It isn't and I think it ages well. I know he said he doesn't understand why Waiting wasn't bigger but I think Kill Something would be a lot better in that place but sure take off Grim Reaping too while we are at it. Otherwise i think it's a great album. I would probably put it third currently in their rankings.
     
  25. JRGComedy

    Prestigious Supporter

    It’s my third as well