It's about even with Self-Titled, which is just slightly trailing Brand New Eyes. Brand New Eyes has some of the best longevity out of really any album I've ever listened to. No matter how many times I've listened to it, I'm always immediately pulled in as soon as Careful starts.
my main problem is that I really don't care for Forgiveness, 26, No Friend or Tell Me How. And on top of that, Fake Happy and Pool aren't really doin much for me either
I think the songs are very thematically similar, so if your not relating to the well "people are so full of shit" mentality that reverberates through the album I can see just not being into it. Fortunately for me, I relate. I love the album. I do think No Friend is a complete waste of a track though.
Yeah there's a few too many that don't do a lot for me too and nothing that I like as much as my favourites on other albums which keeps it from being on the same level as S/T or BNE. I really like the general theme of the lyrics though and think it's some of her best work in that department.
man, forgiveness might be my favorite song on the entire record. not even lyrically, i just find it so soothing. the only song i tend to skip is caught in the middle, but thats growing on me a lot now
I wouldn't say any song is bad but I skip Forgiveness, 26 and No Friend every time now. Not a huge fan of Grudges either.
Not only do I think this is by far paramores best record, this is easily my favorite record of the year and probably one of my all time favorite records. Love love love
I have a hard time listening to their first three albums in full. That walls of guitars kind of thing gets tiring after few songs, but this is the way pop punk mostly is, and I guess that was Josh Farro's main writing style. They became a much more dynamic band starting with S/T. Hayley also doesn't sing like she has to overpower the other instruments anymore which is pretty cool as well.
Just got back from seeing the band out in Europe throughout the last week. They're better than ever and the fun they're having on stage really makes the show. It's almost infectious and I think it really shows when they've played the Halfnoise cover. 90% of the crowd has no idea what they're playing, but the band is up there - throwing on some shades and shaking their banana maracas - and the crowd just dances along with them. New songs were so much fun live, especially Fake Happy. They've done some subtle, but noticeable changes to older songs that freshen them up a bit. Go see them. P.S. Grabbed the setlist and Zac's drumstick, so my life has been made. Someone bury me with them.
Unpopular opinion: I'd put the S/T at #4 in their discography behind After Laughter, BNE, and Riot! respectively. Yes, the band reinvented themselves and hit another level of creativity, but even with the interludes that album just isn't very cohesive and it still feels a little bloated to me. This is coming from someone who loves lengthy records too.
it's my 4th favorite album of theirs which may sound like a knock on the surface but i really really really like riot, bne, and self-titled
It's easily my favourite, partly because it's so diverse. There's only two songs I don't love which is less than every other album of theirs except BNE.
I feel like if they got rid of "Be Alone" (which is a drag) and "Crazy Girls" (which I really like, it's just out of place) and moved the second interlude between "Last Hope" and "Still Into You," it would be tighter and the flow would make more sense. That's my unimportant opinion on the matter. :)
After Laughter is definitely my favorite. Their most cohesive and focused album to date. I love the themes, lyrics, aesthetic, and just about every song. Only weakness is a slight misuse of Aaron Weiss, but I still kind of see what they were going for.
Yeah, I think he was used well. I was scared at first because you really can't hear him well at first, but as his voice rises and becomes more audible it creates a really cool effect. Just him being on an entire song is so darn cool to me.
I like Aaron Weiss a lot more than I like Paramore and it's still my least favourite song on the album, haha.