My list would probably be the releases in reverse chronological order, but AWKIF swapped with Riot. TIW means so much to me and it’s my personal favorite by a large margin but man, is AL a bombshell of a record.
This Is Why and S/T are my favorites. This one could be up there as, stylistically, it aligns much more with my tastes in 2025 than their pre-S/T material. However, it was released at a low point in my life, hence me rarely revisiting it since. Making new memories with it could fix that though. I'll have to think about it because it's a shame to feel like I'm missing out on such a great album.
I dunno, I think AWK is so clearly the worst thing they've done. Doesn't hold up very well at all imo. They got so much better so quickly.
I love it, it's only got better with time for me. It was easily my least favourite at one point but at some point it just started growing on me a ton. It helps that I'm generally a lot more into things that sound like that then things that sound like After Laughter.
Petals for Armor Flowers for Vases could add on the bottom of my list. I like Petals a fair amount but never really got into Vases.