I can’t rank the albums because I don’t think any of them are consistently great, they all have a handful of incredible songs though
i thought vices was mediocre for years until i spent some time with it when death of a bachelor came out. i was wrong, it's great! oddly subtle record tbh
I think Fever has like one weak song but other than that I'd agree that they all have at least a few duds on them.
I don't think Vices or Fever have a single dud among them. The rest all have at least one song that I don't outright love, but TWTL is the only one that I'd say has any duds.
I'm not a huge fan of Camasido. I think Behind the Sea and Mad as Rabbits are both really bad and I don't really like Always or The Calender.
PO's best songs are some of my all-time favorite Panic tracks. Nine In the Afternoon, That Green Gentleman, Northern Downpour, and Mad As Rabbits are classics.
Albums: Odd>Bachelor>Vices>Fever>Weird Songs: I think Golden Days might be the best track they've ever released, and Impossible Year is hella underrated. Other faves include Folkin' Around, This is Gospel, Memories, Northern Downpour.
Okay, I’m ready to say both the new songs are great. Neither wowed me right away but I warmed up to them really quickly.
Morgan Kibby (White Sea, M83) co-wrote for the album, can't tell how many tracks but its seems like a lot? She also co-wrote "Hallelujah," "Victorious" "LA Devotee" and "House of Memories"