it was fun because I used the list of songs of wiki. It’s in alphabetical order so I got to the end, feeling good about about my list and then had to be like “what she said? William it was really nothing? You’ve got everything now? FUCKKKKKKK”
I got into them with White Pony, so I guess it'd look like: 1. Change 2. Back To School 3. Digital Bath 4. Passenger 5. Pink Maggit Because the first ones were the singles and the latter were the album tracks that made me think "Damn, this is a good band."
Love ranking stuff, here are mine for what I've seen here so far that I like: Every Time I Die: Hot Damn! Low Teens Radical Ex-Lives From Parts Unknown Gutter Phenomenon New Junk Aesthetic The Big Dirty Last Night in Town Deftones: White Pony Diamond Eyes Around The Fur Private Music Koi No Yokan Ohms Gore Self Titled Saturday Night Wrist Adrenaline
damn this is not a saturday night wrist kinda site lmao thats okay its got a decked out throne on my podium
White pony Diamond eyes Around the fur Private music Deftones Ohms Koi No Yokan Saturday Night Wrist Gore Adrenaline
1. Digital Bath 2. Elite 3. Rx Queen 4. Hexagram 5. Minerva 6. Diamond Eyes 7. You've Seen the Butcher I know there's 7 here and they're all singles or single-adjacent, but I started with White Pony and Self-Titled and then Diamond Eyes was the first one I was a current fan for, so there are the songs that really opened me up and solidified my love for their sound.
Minerva My Own Summer Diamond Eyes Swerve City Cherry Waves Hexagram Milk of the Madonna these were the songs that made me go like ohhhh.
Modest Mouse releases: The Moon & Antarctica Good News for People Who Love Bad News We Were Dead Before the Ship Even Sank Sharpen Your Teeth (it's Ugly Casanova but I'm counting it) Everywhere and His Nasty Parlour Tricks This is a Long Drive for Someone With Nothing to Think About The Lonesome Crowded West The Golden Casket Building Nothing Out of Something Strangers to Ourselves An Eraser and a Maze No One's First and You're Next Another one of the best bands ever that hasn't made a bad record (Sad Sappy Sucker is more of a curiosity than anything), so no one should take this too personally lol everything here is basically a 7-7.5 or higher. Not ranking Baron Von Bullshit. Interstate 8, or Night on the Sun since one is a live record and the other two are comprised of material that appears elsewhere in the discography.
Question. How many records do you need to have released to properly rank a discography? Is Thursday's 6 enough? Full Collapse WATT No Devolucion ACBTLD Waiting Common Existence
THURSDAY War All The Time Full Collapse A City By The Light Divided No Devolucion Common Existence Waiting
6 is for sure enough, i would say three is probably realistically the bare minimum thursday! no bad albums 1. no devolucion 2. common existence 3. war all the time 4. waiting 5. full collapse 6. a city by the light divided modest mouse! uhh almost there! 1. the lonesome crowded west 2. long drive 3. the moon & antarctica 4. we were dead 5. an eraser and a maze 6. good news 7. strangers to ourselves 8. the golden casket
Golden Casket is good. And ACBTLD last is craaaaazy THURSDAY Common Existence A City By the Light Divided No Devolucion Waiting Full Collapse War All the Time
yea aaron you and i most definitely do not seem to rank anything the same as each other so far lol and that is cool too i personally think that is part of the fun, seeing the prioritization of completely different records that i do but the same fervency for the artists is imo what makes ranking anything worthwhile
Trophy Scars (as on 6/30/26 because I change my mind on this all the time): Holy Vacants Bad Luck Never Born, Never Dead Darkness, Oh Hell Alphabet. Alphabets. Astral Pariah Hospital Music for the Aesthetics of Language Goodnight Alchemy Darts to the Sea
Untouchables See You On The Other Side The Serenity Of Suffering The Nothing Korn Untitled Issues Take A Look In The Mirror Follow The Leader Requiem Life Is Peachy Korn III: Remember Who You Are The Path Of Totality The Paradigm Shift