Oops, All Rankings! • Page 13

Discussion in 'Music Forum' started by Aaron Mook, Jun 29, 2026.

  1. waking season

    Trusted Prestigious

    Led Zeppelin II
    Led Zeppelin IV
    Led Zeppelin
    Houses of the Holy
    Led Zeppelin III
    Physical Graffiti
    Presence
    In Through the Out Door
     
    hch827 likes this.
  2. Friendjamin

    Trusted Supporter

    Deafheaven

    Infinite Granite (I'm going to get crucified for this lol)
    Sunbather
    Lonely People with Power
    New Bermuda
    Ordinary Corrupt Human Love

    I've never listened to Roads to Judah (should I? It's not super high on anyone's list)
     
    trevorshmevor and waking season like this.
  3. waking season

    Trusted Prestigious

    I respect it, I really enjoy Infinite Granite. Roads to Judah is still a very solid album, I just like everything else more.
     
    Friendjamin likes this.
  4. peoplearepoison

    It takes strength to be gentle and kind Supporter

    Infinite Granite is my third favorite. I loved the risk it was; I thought they pulled it off flawlessly.

    road to Judah is good. It def sounds more like an undercooked and worship of bands in the genre, but it’s still quality.

     
    Friendjamin and waking season like this.
  5. Jon

    Regular

    I have a soft spot for Roads of Judah since I heard that before Sunbather came out since I'm near the Bay area. But I would put it on the bottom half of their discography. I still recommend it though if you are a fan especially if you want to see how they evolved
     
    Aaron Mook and Friendjamin like this.
  6. JM95

    hmmm

    Deftones:
    Around The Fur
    White Pony
    Deftones
    Private Music
    Diamond Eyes
    Adrenaline
    Koi No Yokan
    Ohms
    Gore
    Saturday Night Wrist

    Reuben/Jamie Lenman:
    Racecar is Racecar Backwards
    In Nothing We Trust
    Muscle Memory
    Very Fast Very Dangerous
    Devolver
    King of Clubs
    The Atheist

    Morrissey's 80s and 90s solo albums:
    Your Arsenal
    Bona Drag
    Vauxhall and I
    Viva Hate
    Kill Uncle
    Southpaw Grammar
    Maladjusted
     
    Aaron Mook and peoplearepoison like this.
  7. Penlab

    Prestigious Supporter

    Such a wild opinion to me when Wrist has Beware, Cherry Waves, Xerces, Kimdracula, etc.
     
  8. JM95

    hmmm

    I really like about half of Wrist. But I don't care for Mein, Combat, Pink Cellphone, and Rapture. And tbh I'm completely indifferent to Xerces. I find that slow, slightly hollow atmospheric thing more intense and captivating on a moodier, more despairing song like Deathblow from the self-titled. So even though there are killer songs on Wrist, I think it stumbles and lags quite regularly. The recent revision of it as one of their best is bizarre to me.

    Whereas I've always been a fan of the flow on Gore. Even the lesser songs on there are interesting to me in their context, and that slightly scratchy, blown-out, mid-heavy mix, though it unforgivably buries Abe at times, has this strange psychedelic appeal to me, which then grounds perfectly at the end with Phantom Bride and Rubicon. It's nowhere close to their zenith but I'd rather listen to it as a full album than Wrist.
     
    Aaron Mook likes this.
  9. Penlab

    Prestigious Supporter

    To each their own, I guess. I think Rapture rocks, I find Xerces to be a somber but powerful song, and while it took me some time for Mein, Combat, and Pink Cellphone to grow on me, I do appreciate them as interesting breaks in the album's flow, although I tend to skip over that final bit of Cellphone still...

    Meanwhile, Gore I have just bounced off every time I've listened to it. Being honest, all of Deftones' latter era albums took time to grow on me, and while I once bounced off Koi No Yokan and Ohms, the former is now one of if not my favorite album of theirs and Ohms is just sensational.

    Gore though has still not been able to get anywhere with me. I literally could not tell you how a single song on that album goes, and I've listened to it multiple times.
     
  10. I'm with @JM95 . SNW has grown on me over time and I appreciate it for being a transitional record with some really high highs, but as a whole, I find Gore to be more fleshed out and cohesive (feature me for, ubg for others perhaps). I also just reach for it a lot more often as far as underrated Deftones records go.

    Also, re: Deafheaven - Roads to Judah is very good and people should listen to it.
     
    Friendjamin and waking season like this.
  11. Dinkleberg

    Go birds Supporter

    Roads to Judah is a vibe. I don’t think it has peaks quite as high as their other albums, but I value the consistency in the mood of Roads to Judah over Ordinary Corrupt Human Love and Infinite Granite. I feel more compelled to listen to RTJ in its entirety than those two
     
    Friendjamin and Aaron Mook like this.
  12. web250

    I'll change this eventually Prestigious

    Touche

    Stage Four
    Parting The Sea Between Brightness And Me
    Lament
    Spiral In A Straight Line
    To The Beat Of A Dead Horse
    Is Survived By


    Deafheaven

    Sunbather
    LPWP
    New Bermuda
    OCHL
    Roads to Judah
    Infinite Granite (dead last 30 feet below the earth)
     
    Aaron Mook likes this.
  13. Frieren

    Elf

    Coheed

    In Keeping Secrets
    GAI
    Afterman (as one album)
    SSTB
    Vaxis 1
    NWFT
    Vaxis 3
    VaxIs 2
    TCBTS




    YoTBR
     
  14. Penlab

    Prestigious Supporter

    Toxicity
    System Of A Down
    Hypnotize
    Mesmerize
    Steal This Album

    The End Of All Things To Come
    Lost And Found
    LD50
    The New Game
    Mudvayne

    Fallen
    Evanescence
    The Bitter Truth
    Sanctuary
    The Open Door
     
  15. peoplearepoison

    It takes strength to be gentle and kind Supporter

    Taking Back Sunday

    New Again
    Where You Want To Be
    Louder Now
    Tell All Your Friends
    Tidal Wave
    Happiness Is
    Taking Back Sunday
    152
     
    Penlab likes this.
  16. Penlab

    Prestigious Supporter

    See, I'm just a friendly little party crasher. Here though, this is true chaos.
     
  17. amorningofsleep

    Everyone's head rings here

    Minus the Bear

    Planet of Ice
    Menos el Oso
    Omni
    Highly Refined Pirates
    Infinity Overhead
    Voids
     
    waking season and Chcurry182 like this.
  18. Chcurry182

    Trusted Supporter

    Voids that low is criminal.
     
  19. Dinkleberg

    Go birds Supporter

    Minus The Bear

    Menos el Oso
    Planet of Ice
    They Make Beer Commercials Like This
    Infinity Overhead
    Highly Refined Pirates
    OMNI
    Fair Enough
    This is What I Know About Being Gigantic
    Voids
     
  20. Fucking Dustin

    Spicy Member Moderator

    Thread is over a week old and @CarpetElf has 0 posts in here I am disappointed
     
  21. Chcurry182

    Trusted Supporter

    I guess I'm alone in loving Voids.

    Minus The Bear

    Menos el Oso
    Planet of Ice
    Voids
    OMNI
    Highly Refined Pirates
    They Make Beer Commercials Like This
    Infinity Overhead
     
  22. Dinkleberg

    Go birds Supporter

    Indigo, CarpetElf and Fucking Dustin like this.
  23. Where You Want to Be
    Louder Now
    Tell All Your Friends
    New Again
    Happiness Is
    Taking Back Sunday
    Tidal Wave
    152
     
    Chcurry182 likes this.
  24. Dinkleberg

    Go birds Supporter

    Voids has a few good songs and some cool moments, but there are some songs on there that absolutely bog the album down for me and I’m not a fan of the mix. I don’t think it’s a bad album by any means, but I’ve tried and tried and tried and I don’t think it’s good
     
  25. Chcurry182

    Trusted Supporter

    Switch Happiness Is and Taking Back Sunday and this would be my order as well.
     
    Fucking Dustin likes this.