On the Impossible Bracket (The Menzingers Bracket) Bracket • Page 63

After the Party - 12
Casey - 10

 

Casey

 

Your Wild Years should be here but it’s not so...

After The Party

This wasn’t even a difficult choice. Both songs are good but one is significantly better than the other.

 

After the Party - 13
Casey - 11

 

after the party

 

Please let this end in a tie like the first bayside bracket

 

NO

 

After the Party - 14
Casey - 11

 

Legit two of my favourite songs of all time.

One reminds me of the end of a four year relationship, and the sort of uncertainty and regret that follows a relationship of that magnitude ending, whilst another reminds me of the experience of discovering yourself and moving on.

Both of these songs mean a lot to me, and on top of that I think they are hands down the best songs of their career so it is a fitting final of two very different elements of a great band.

So, for those reasons, After The Party, just.

 

after the party

thanks for hosting 333 its been fun

 

Casey

 

this could honestly go either way for me, since I think both songs are equally important in their discography. After the Party has some of Greg's best lyrics but Casey is quintessential menzingers with my favorite Philly reference of theirs.

That being said, I'm going with After the Party. For a band that does nostalgia so well, this might be one of their best

 

Casey

 

Party

 

After the Party - 18
Casey - 13

Looks like we may have our winner, but I'll leave this open for a few more hours just to be safe.

 

My pleasure!

 

Let's see two songs with Philly references about girls/past relationships that are oozing with nostalgia and vivid imagery. They are two of my favorite Menzos tracks and although I think After the Party has better lyrics, my OTIP love is causing me to vote for Casey.

 

After the Party - 18
Casey - 14

Anyone else?

 

Game over. We have our winner.

Congratulations to AFTER THE PARTY for winning the first Chorus.fm Menzingers bracket!

Thank you to everyone for participating! This was a breeze to run, and I had a lot of fun doing it!

 

That was a fun one!

 

And if you want more bracket fun, come to the Bring Me the Horizon bracket that just started this morning ;)