It probably was middle tier for me but they play it often and everyone always hypes it, making it one of my least favorite on the album. Gates
Gates is such a good song but Casey is the quintessential Menz tune, and maybe the catchiest one they've ever written IMO
Closing this later than expected (festivities got in the way), but the time has come to call it. Final scores: Gates - 9 Casey - 22 CASEY has won the On the Impossible Past bracket and will be moving on to the championship rounds.
RENTED WORLD ROUND 1 ___________ Hearts Unknown vs. Sentimental Physics Where Your Heartache Exists vs. The Talk Nothing Feels Good Anymore vs. My Friend Kyle When You Died vs. Bad Things
Hearts Unknown (not big fan of either song really) Heartache (One of my favorites on the album) Nothing (Super underrated tune and I've always favored Greg over Tom for the most part) When You Died (Greg's best Bob Dylan impression and a song I wish they'd play live sometime)
Hearts Unknown The Talk Nothing Feels Good Anymore Bad Things (When You Died is one of my least favorite Menzingers songs, never really cared for it)
Hearts Unknown - 6 Sentimental Physics - 0 Where Your Heartache Exists - 3 The Talk - 3 Nothing Feels Good Anymore - 6 My Friend Kyle - 0 When You Died - 4 Bad Things - 2
Hearts Unknown Where Your Heartache Exists Nothing Feels Good Anymore Bad Things (I think Bad Things is a dope song)
@333 GANG any way you can leave this open until tomorrow morning? i need to give the album another listen (it’s been awhile!) but i’m all tied up today