Like just pick a bad team and give them the choice between Puka and Stroud and 100% of them are picking Stroud.
Which is exactly what I'm saying! There is weight to it where the award is automatically going to any rookie QB that was remotely good and it doesn't matter how good anyone else was. Which is why they should switch to All-Rookie teams instead
Can’t it also be true that Puka can be rookie of the year for having the best statistical season ever? Also who cares. Most of the greatest players ever never sniffed rookie of the year. They’re both awesome and likely to be awesome for a while
questionable on if it was holding or not. Jersey held but I don’t know if it changed his positioning. Is Jersey in hand supposed to be auto flag?
And everyone else is bumping on your instance that stroud has only been “remotely good” and not having one of the most special rookie seasons a QB has ever had.