The Sound of Two Voices and The Cheapest Thrill are really the songs here that remind me of being first introduced to NFG and getting hooked on S&S.
I mean, totally fair. And I eat up early '00s pop punk. I still listen to most of it. Just never got why people liked that record. I know that makes me somewhat of a heretic ;)
Definitely NFG's best album by a long shot imo. I'm sure most of you wouldn't agree with this but I don't think they ever succeeded across an entire album anywhere near the level of S&S
Yeah. I think it's in my top 4 best pop punk albums ever. It changed/helped invent the genre for the next decade basically. Just an outright classic imo.
That, Sound of Two Voices, and Call Me Anti-Social are my favorites. Might change. But yeah, I really like say it don't spray it.
I definitely don't deny the influence, but there is a huge chunk of this album (basically after the first couple tracks) that I've just never been that interested in. I always give it another chance every couple months but it never really clicks. What I've noticed though is that a lot of similar albums (Say it Like You Mean it, Chroma, Take This to Your Grave, All Killer No Filler, etc.) clicked with me in middle school/high school and I still like those ones, but albums that I either didn't listen to or didn't like back then (Through Being Cool, S&S, Simple Plan's stuff, Good Charlotte's stuff) are much harder to get into now. I feel like if you miss connecting with these records at a certain time period you might not care about them much when you're older, even if you can realize why people like them.
Pop punk to me is S&S, Enema, and All Killer No Filler. Those aren't necessarily my favorites from the bands now, but when I think what is pop punk, those are the three records that define the genre to me. Clearly derived from punk, but with a strong nod to catchy pop music.
Interesting to see everyone loving "Sound of Two Voices". That's easily my least favorite track on this haha. In other news, I went for a bike ride around the lake today and listened to this twice and it was quite enjoyable.
You definitely have a point. That's basically why I can't get into early FOB or TSL, among others. I totally missed that 2000-2004 period and only really started paying attention to music around 2007.