Remove ads, unlock a dark mode theme, and get other perks by upgrading your account. Experience the website the way it's meant to be.

My Life In 35 Songs, Track 8: “Feeling a Moment” by Feeder

Discussion in 'Article Discussion' started by Melody Bot, May 13, 2025 at 8:42 AM.

  1. Melody Bot

    Your friendly little forum bot. Staff Member

    This article has been imported from chorus.fm for discussion. All of the forum rules still apply.

    Turning to face what you’ve become, bury the ashes of someone

    I love the way it breaks the silence.

    If you’ve never heard “Feeling a Moment” before, do yourself a favor and click play on that YouTube video down below, or go cue it up on your preferred streaming service. You’ll hear what I mean: a few seconds of something played backwards, and then a torrent of sound – an electric guitar strum and a wordless wail. For me, it is the sound of everything I was feeling at the start of my ninth-grade year: nerves, excitement, anticipation, self-belief and self-doubt in equal measure, and more than a little bit of fear.

    Because what’s scarier than a totally new frontier? I’ve got the answer: being dropped into said new frontier in your early teens.

    I wrote a couple chapters ago about how absolutely terrified I was at the prospect of moving away from my home and my friends on the brink of high school. I really did not want to become that character you always see in movies – the “new kid” who doesn’t know anybody and has to start over completely from scratch in the unwelcoming halls of a high school. I dodged that bullet in 2004, but I don’t think I fully grasped at the time how much I was going to end up living it one year later regardless.

    The way public school was structured in my hometown was as follows: grades K-6 were at the elementary schools, grades 7-9 were at the “junior high,” and grades 10-12 were at the high school. Your freshman year, in other words, was weirdly apportioned off as part of middle school. It was an illogical way of doing things, and it felt even weirder for me, as someone who’d attended a separate charter school for eight years and was now getting dumped out into the junior high for a single year before switching schools again a year later. If freshman year had been at the high school building, then every one of my fellow ninth graders would have been feeling some version of the wrong-footing I felt on that first day of high school in 2005. Instead, I was one of the few new students in a big school where everyone already knew one another.

    “Feeling a Moment,” a sublime U2-sized anthem from Welsh rock band Feeder, was not the first song I played on the morning of my first day of school, mostly because I didn’t know it existed yet. The first time I heard this song was at the top of the season 3 premiere of One Tree Hill, which would air a month after I started school, on October 5. From there, though, “Feeling a Moment” became my freshman year anthem. Seven or eight years ago, when I made a series of 18-song nostalgia mixes for each of my school years, “Feeling a Moment” was my go-to opening track for the ninth-grade mix. It’s also the opener for Pushing the Senses, the 2005 Feeder LP produced by legendary studio maven Gil Norton; it’s the second of three Norton-produced tracks that will appear in this series, after “Kill” from Jimmy Eat World’s Futures and before…well, I’ll let you guess.

    Some songs just feel like they are coursing with electricity and adrenaline, and “Feeling a Moment” is one of those songs. The entire track is charged with kinetic energy, like a runaway train car hurtling down a mountainside. The big wordless vocal melody giving way to the calm-in-the-storm verses, which in turn hand the baton off to the massive, massive chorus, which itself builds to the even bigger-sounding bridge. It is a viscerally exciting song, and it was the perfect soundtrack for a viscerally exciting time, when virtually every single thing in my life felt brand new.

    It turned out that being the “new kid” wasn’t so bad. Almost every classmate from my old school had known me for so long that, in certain ways, it felt like my identity and my personality had been locked into place. Moving to a new school offered an opportunity to break free of that version of myself, and to rebuild a new me in its place. New friends and relationships, new interests and hobbies, new extracurricular activities, new academic focus areas, a new personality. Everything was so fresh and groundbreaking, and I could feel myself changing and growing in real time as I experienced it all.

    Along with all the new that came from this fresh start, I felt this incredible pull to search out and embrace new music. It was one of two times in my life – the other following my graduation from college – where the break from my past life felt significant enough to demand a totally new soundtrack. For at least the first few months, I don’t recall listening much to the music that had been dominating my life up to that point. Instead, I poured myself fully into new albums and new artists. Something Corporate and Jack’s Mannequin for my angsty days; Fall Out Boy and Motion City Soundtrack to connect with my emo-loving classmates; Jamie Cullum and his contemporary jazz to feel a little bit classier than usual; Josh Ritter for my budding songwriting enthusiast side. Years later, I’d make a 1,200-song playlist cataloging my entire youth, from childhood to college graduation. The stretch of songs that makes up ninth grade – which spans 90 or so tracks – is one of my favorite parts of the playlist, just because it reflects the fertile period of discovery I was going through at that time.

    A lot of that music came just by virtue of having new people in my orbit to bounce off of, but I think most of it came from TV shows. By ninth grade, I had two iPods, an ever-growing mp3 library, and no interest in checking in with what was getting played on top 40 radio. Lucky for me, though, this was a time in history where TV networks were shelling out the big bucks to license half a dozen songs per episode, and most of those songs were great. The O.C. was the poster child for this trend, teaching an entire generation of teenagers that the coolest thing they could do was listen to obscure indie rock. But I loved One Tree Hill for its more emo-leaning impulses, Smallville for its grungier alternative rock mix, Grey’s Anatomy for its devotion to making adult contemporary music sound vital and profound, and Scrubs or Gilmore Girls for being a little off-kilter and all over the place. There are even some totally forgotten shows from this era that I remember exclusively because they were the first place I heard great, great songs – like Nada Surf’s “Inside Your Love” popping up on a thoroughly mediocre WB melodrama called The Mountain, or Oasis’s “Stop Crying Your Heart Out” lending some weight to Fox’s trashy Hawaii-set drama North Shore.

    By ninth grade, that era of TV show music was already starting to peter out. The O.C., so gargantuan in its first two seasons, was suddenly skating on thin ice in its crappy third outing, and you could tell that shows like Smallville were dedicating smaller portions of their budgets to the soundtrack. But for the moment, so much of my music discovery was still driven by the music supervisors on TV shows that were punching well above their weight in terms of soundtrack development. It wasn’t just current music, either. Hell, One Tree Hill was the first place I heard The Replacements’ “Here Comes a Regular” and Led Zeppelin’s “Babe I’m Gonna Leave You,” two absolutely classic songs that I can’t believe got licensed for an increasingly off-the-wall teenage soap.

    Freshman year ended up being a whirlwind, transitional time in my life, and I’d be lying if I said every moment along the way was good. On the contrary, I remember breathing a big sigh of relief when the bell rang on the last day and I got to walk out of that school building for the last time. I felt like I’d spent the entire year as a puzzle piece trying to find its place, only to realize that I was trying to slot my way into the wrong puzzle. When I listen back to “Feeling a Moment,” that quest for belonging is what I hear, in every wordless cry and soaring chorus. I’d find my place soon enough, but this song was an anthem for the fruitless but often glorious search. Maybe more than any other song, I hear it now as the sound of growing up.

    Past Installments:

    more

    Not all embedded content is displayed here. You can view the original to see embedded videos and other embedded content.
     
  2. JohnOC

    New single "Sands of Time" out now!

    Pushing the Senses is a phenomenal album! I'm surprised they never made it in the US. Them and Kasabian would be a tour that could do arenas/stadiums in Europe, but would struggle to sell out 800 person venues here.
     
    Craig Manning and RaginCajun like this.
  3. RaginCajun

    Better than you, sorry

    I never thought I’d see the day y’all talk about feeder…

    The band that I have the most vinyls from. high, yesterday went too soon, echo park, pushing the senses, and singles album to name a few.

    And with the song you named “don’t ever feel that you’re alone I’ll never let you down”
     
    Jetslickz and Craig Manning like this.
  4. Massive, MASSIVE song. I love Pushing the Senses a ton. I don't know if there is a better one-two punch of singles in the anthemic rock stratosphere than "Feeling a Moment" and the title track.

    I have such a soft spot for this band because of this album, but it's kind of a detriment to the rest of their catalog how much I love it. Nothing else in their discography quite scratches this itch (though Comfort in Sound gets close), and it's kept me from forming a stronger connection with the band as a whole.
     
    Jetslickz and Craig Manning like this.
  5. Craig Manning

    @FurtherFromSky Moderator

    They just seem like one of those overseas band that never got a real push in America. It's a shame, because Pushing the Senses especially is so strong and so radio friendly. I feel like some of those songs could have been hits. Maybe if that album had hit a few years earlier, they would have been.

    This is definitely the least well-known band I've tackled in this series so far, and I expect the engagement will be down a bit because of that. But man, this song rules. I couldn't not include it.

    Jealous of your Pushing the Senses vinyl. I hope they re-press that one someday, because it's hard to find for a reasonable sum of money. I did see that they're re-pressing Comfort in Sound this year, so maybe it'll happen.

    I am just now exploring their discography beyond Pushing the Senses, and I'm really digging Comfort in Sound. It's not quite as strong, but it has similar appeal.

    Pushing the Senses is almost Hot Fuss level in how good that first half is. I like the second half too, but those first five songs flow so well and are all so fucking good.
     
    Patterns in Traffic likes this.
  6. Michael Schmidt

    Trusted Supporter

    Very nice piece! What an insane grade to building setup, given how most states and the country approaches things. Is it still like that, do you know?
     
    Jason Tate and Craig Manning like this.
  7. Craig Manning

    @FurtherFromSky Moderator

    lol, no, it changed like two years later. I guess they decided it was stupid (which it was!)
     
    Jason Tate and Michael Schmidt like this.
  8. AlwaysEvolving21

    Trusted Supporter

    Another banger.

    Another OTH song! That's how I heard it for the first time too.
     
    simplejack and Craig Manning like this.
  9. Craig Manning

    @FurtherFromSky Moderator

    I checked my One Tree Hill playlist on iTunes. 300 songs!
     
  10. simplejack

    Still Alive

    Yeah, One Tree Hill strikes again!

    Feeling the Moment is one of those songs you can always count on when you want to start a playlist strong. Incredible track, still rings in my ears after all these years.

    Another great chapter, the writing resonates within me as usual.
     
    Craig Manning likes this.
  11. Cr0akz

    :P

    Still my favourite band to this day. Started with Echo Park when I was about 13. I remember getting my CD player confiscated in class two years later as I covertly listened to Comfort In Sound. I don't have anywhere near the number of playlists for other bands as I do with Feeder. Even this far into their career they're still putting out great records - their most recent a double album! That's not to say I love everything they do - Renegades and All Bright Electric never really struck a chord with me - but the sheer weight of great songs over the years makes creating any one playlist for them a real challenge.

    Anyway, it's really nice to see them mentioned on here.
     
    Craig Manning likes this.
  12. David87

    Prestigious Prestigious

    I am on the "9th graders belong in middle school" train after teaching 9th graders the last 8 years lol. We should go back to 7-9 being "junior high" all in the same building again like the old days
     
    Craig Manning likes this.
  13. Craig Manning

    @FurtherFromSky Moderator

    Gotta say, I'm pleasantly surprised at how many Feeder fans are coming out of the woodwork here. I figured this chapter wouldn't get much love, just because it's a less well-known song than, like, "Fix You." But this is cool to see!
     
  14. Craig Manning

    @FurtherFromSky Moderator

    Haha, is it just a maturity thing, or what?
     
  15. David87

    Prestigious Prestigious

    Oh yeah, they're wayyyyyyy more middle school than high school. It's such a stark difference from 9th to 10th grade. Maybe being new to the building and not "knowing how to act" yet is part of it, but also it's just that age, 13-15 year olds are just on another level of insanity compared to the rest of the adolescents lol. Once you hit 10th grade, most of the kids seem to mellow out a bit more.
     
    Craig Manning likes this.
  16. Craig Manning

    @FurtherFromSky Moderator

    Yeah, I can totally see that. I was old for my grade, so that probably added to my feeling that I wanted to be at the high school rather than the junior high. There was so. much. drama. across grades 7-9, and I wanted nothing to do with most of it. lol
     
    David87 likes this.
  17. Jetslickz

    Newbie

    Very well said. This song was in a lot of sporting montages in British media back in the day. I remember hearing this banger in the 2007 football (soccer) film Goal II. Feeder are an underrated band and it's great seeing more Americans being able to appreciate them, too.
     
    Cr0akz and Craig Manning like this.
  18. Craig Manning

    @FurtherFromSky Moderator

    Yeah, this song being used in football coverage and films does not surprise me at all. It's perfect for that. (Great running song, too.) I recall the first Goal film using both "Some Might Say" by Oasis and "Paint the Silence" by South, so this song is in good company there.
     
  19. This thread inspired me to dive into Feeder's discography again, starting at the beginning. I've probably heard these albums once or twice ever, and not for over 10 years.

    Can't believe how much I'm enjoying Polythene. I remember bouncing off their early stuff years ago, but now I'm finding the album to be an infectious and nostalgic mix of pop and post grunge. Similar to a lot of bands I was listening to in the early 2000s, but much better and more consistent. Going on three days in a row listening to this album.
     
    Craig Manning likes this.
  20. Cr0akz

    :P

    I remember hearing Feeling A Moment on MasterChef once. Pushing The Senses used to be on a car ad. Their songs still get around.
     
    Craig Manning likes this.
  21. Craig Manning

    @FurtherFromSky Moderator

    I need to do a deep dive as well. Polythene will be on the list for today.
     
    Patterns in Traffic likes this.
  22. JohnOC

    New single "Sands of Time" out now!

    I've first heard Morning Life from the movie Remember the Daze. I don't think I've heard that song anywhere else, which is a shame. Looking at Setlist FM, I don't even think they play that song live.
     
  23. Craig Manning

    @FurtherFromSky Moderator

    Really enjoying my listen to this record this morning. These guys were really locking into that signature '90s sound. "Descend" in particular rules.
     
    Patterns in Traffic likes this.
  24. Yeah that is a good one. Strangely enough, I find the first track to be one of the weakest. After that, pretty much every song had an aspect that grabbed me on first (re)listen.

    I'm two listens into Yesterday Went Too Soon and I found it much less immediate the first time around, but it already started sinking in on listen two. They show a much more melodic side on that one, a pretty significant shift for a sophomore album. I think its length hurts it a little, but I'm going to give it a few more listens because it seems like a lot of long-time fans consider it their best album.
     
    Craig Manning likes this.
  25. Craig Manning

    @FurtherFromSky Moderator

    I'm struck by how different this first album sounds from the Comfort in Sound/Pushing the Senses era that I'm familiar with. More Smashing Pumpkins than U2.
     
    Patterns in Traffic likes this.