Movies That Didn’t Actually Happen • Page 166

Are you though?

 

The night before absolutely rules. Thread ban for penlab.

 

The weird part is you guys are acting like I'm saying it's a bad film when it's been specifically said several times in this thread that's not what this thread is for.

 

The Night Before doesn't belong in this thread, but to give Penlab a little credit, I do think it's maybe one of the more forgotten/overlooked Rogen movies.

 

I think he's been in a lot more movies than you think haha. Just off the top of my head, there's that movie with Charlize Theron that I don't think anybody knows exists.

But yeah Night Before definitely happened. It might not have happened back when it originally came out, but it has since happened

 

I will give penlab no credit.

 

the long shot also rules and totally happened.

 

I love when someone puts a controversial movie in here

 

Hell, Night Before isn't even the least happened movie that stars Seth Rogan and JGL, though the other one def happened more when it first released compared to Night Before.

 

not saying it's his most forgotten movie, just that when people mention Seth Rogen, Superbad, Knocked Up, Pineapple Express usually come up first. You're definitely right that he has WAY more weird shit in his resume though.

This one for sure never happened.



edit: guess I did say "most" forgotten. I take that back.

 

Is this quantum?

 

Like I want credit from the cops.

 

Yes.

 

His run in the early-mid 2000s is absolutely ridiculous. 2007/8 alone is a whole goddamn career, but every one of his acting credits on wikipedia before 2007 were hits or cult classics too. Wild

 

The wild thing is critics liked this more than The Night Before.

 

I watched an American Pickle on a flight and I remember liking it but I can’t remember a single thing so I’m gonna say it didn’t happen

 

"The film stars Seth Rogen as an Eastern European Jewish immigrant who gets preserved in a vat of pickles and wakes up a century later in modern-day New York City"

 

that doesn’t make sense Dave!

 

feels a little weird to have an american pickle here seeing it’s the first hbo max exclusive film

 

the night before doesn’t belong here, though at the time it did feel like it came and went

 

Nah 50/50 also happened

 

Seems a little weird for HBO to make their first exclusive a Movie That Never Happened

 

You’ve all forced me to post a Seth movie that doesn’t actually exist

 

movie is fun as hell