Motion City Soundtrack - The Same Old Wasted Wonderful World (September 19, 2025) • Page 30

I think Even If It Kills Me is their worst album tbh

 

I think it's their best maybe 2nd after Commit.

Broken Heart, Last Night, Fell In Love, Even If, Had To Be You

Those are all top 10 MCS.

The b-sides are great too (The Worst Part, Not Asking You To Leave)

 

Ugh fine

Commit
EIIKM
MDL
Go
SOWWW
IATM
PS

 

IATM
Commit
Go
MDL
EIIKM
SOWWW
PS

 

Commit
EIIKM
IATM
MDL
SOWWW
Go
PS

Probably not much distance between MDL and SOWWW

 

Even If It Kills Me
Commit This To Memory

My Dinosaur Life
Same Old Wasted Wonderful World
Go

I Am The Movie
Panic Stations

 

I don't really see much disparity in quality between any of their albums, I think they've always been quite consistent.

 

Even If It Kills Me
My Dinosaur Life
Commit This To Memory

Same Old Wasted Wonderful World
Go

I Am The Movie
Panic Stations

 

Feeling sick to my stomach seeing I Am The Movie being ranked so low

 

CTTM
IATM/EIIKM
MDL/SOWWW

GO
PS

That’s it. That’s the list.

 

You’ll be fine.

 

Wrong band but great album

 

MDL
Commit
EIIKM
IATM
Go
SOWWW
PS

 

Wrong band but great album

 

Now I need some tummy medicine.

 

Ugh I can't do a ranking but I'm pretty sure Commit This To Memory and My Dinosaur Life are my top two.

 

Here we go:

Commit This To Memory
I Am The Movie

Even If It Kills Me
The Same Old Wasted Wonderful World
My Dinosaur Life

Panic Stations
Go

 

EIIKM
Commit
IATM
MDL
Go
SOWWW
PS

I almost want to put Commit at #1 just for Hold Me Down.

 

Side note but this new record really grew on me this past weekend and I’m loving the majority of it!

 

Even If It Kills Me
Commit This To Memory
I Am The Movie
Go
My Dinosaur Life
The Same Old Wasted Wonderful World
Panic Stations

 

+1 on this ranking. CTTM edges out EIIKM during certain parts of the year for me though.

 

Yeah, it just never hit for me overall outside the two singles. I was floored when "Everything is Alright" dropped and we got the first taste of what was coming with their sophomore effort. Such a special time period in my life.

 

I don't want to do a real ranking, all I know is CTTM and MDL are high and PS is my least favorite by quite a large margin.

 

IMO, just about as close as the two best albums in a band’s discography can be.

 

I love their first four records all more or less the same amount, then Go and (probably, when all is said and done) the new one a little less than that.

Panic Stations I pretty much only like I Can Feel You but it’s such a top-tier MCS song to me it basically validates that whole album’s existence.