mewithoutYou Band • Page 28

Dis my fav band AMA

 

rank the albums?

 

Are your eyes really Coffee?

 

BS=CFUTF>PH>TS>Crazy>AB but love them all like children

yes they're even brownish with a hint of green

 

Brother, Sister
Catch For Us the Foxes
A->B Life
It's All Crazy
Pale Horses
Ten Stories

 

I know, I know, rankings are arbitrary and often don't stimulate conversation

However

B,S
Ten Stories
Pale Horses
CFUTF
Its All Crazy!
AB

 

guys noooooooo i was making a joke don't do it

 

Hmm. It seems it would be too late.

 

My Exit, Unfair has gone from being one of my least favourites on CFUTF to being tied with Nice and Blue 2 for my fav mwY song.

 

mine is the same except replace the = with a >

 

Spot on ranking and description!

 

PH>BS>CFUTF>TS>AB>Crazy

 

This. I can get behind the ranking either way though.

 

PH=BS=TS>crazy=CFUTF


And I've stopped ranking AB life because it's just not a style I'm into.

 

Catch
TS
B,S
PH
AB

Still haven't heard crazy.

 

After finally listening to AB in preparation for the show I went to, I think it's... not very good. Silencer is a great song, Bullet To Binary is decent, and everything else ranges from aggressively meh to just plain bad. I recognize that it's an important part of their history, but I don't see it as a record I am inclined to return to much if at all in the future.

 

I like AB more every time I go back to it.

 

Yeah, other than Bullet to Binary and Nice & Blue I never return to A -> B. Only mewithoutYou album I don't absolutely adore.

 

Whaaat. Gentlemen is awesome, We Know Who Our Enemies Are is great, and The Cure for Pain is a great closer. A, B, Everything was Beautiful, Be Still Child, and I Never Said are ok, but they're still good songs on their own.

 

Gentlemen got me into the band and it's still one of my favorites of theirs. I'm not so into AB besides that but it's cool that they're playing songs off it, seems like they had avoided that album for a while at their shows.

 

Yeah, I also like AB the more I revisit it, but that doesn't and will never change that it's just not as good as the rest of their discography. also

Smiths references where???

 

"You at 32 still tied to your poor mothers apron strings" is a reference to The Queen Is Deads title track.
"My faith in love is still devout" is a direct reference to "Rusholme Ruffians"
The Ferris wheel line is also a semi reference

 

Faith in love is still devout is from Rusholme Ruffians which is a fantastic song.

I love The Smiths.

 

whoops yep youre right i was on mobile when i typed that and wasnt thinking