mewithoutYou - [untitled] e.p. & [Untitled] LP (2018) Album • Page 33

Nice and Blue 2
My Exit Unfair
Wolf Am I!
Rainbow Signs
Fox's Dream
Red Cow
January 1979
In a Sweater Poorly Knit
Carousels
A Glass Can Only Spill

 

damnit okay


Rainbow Signs
O' Porcupine
Messes Of Men
Paper Hanger
Red Cow
Fox's Dream of the Log Flume
In A Sweater Poorly Knit
Torches Together
February 8th, 1878 SOUTH OF TROUT CREEK WEST OF CEDAR LAKE
Watermelon Ascot

 

top ten??? impossible

 

this ^^^

 

the stupid thing though is there are like 3 songs i would for sure always keep but other than that i could make 5 more of these lists haha

 

fox's dream of the log flume
winter solstice
magic lantern days
c minor
o porcupine
mexican war streets
east enders wives
cattail down
paper-hanger
wolf am i! (and shadow)

 

that was unsatisfying and frustrating

 

It's like asking a parent which of their children is their favorite but much harder.

 

"east enders wives" would be on any configuration of that list i made, i fell in love with aaron's lyrics for the first time when i heard "slowly sank like a shipwrecked sun"

 

wolf am I rips everything up

 

This, but swap Winter Solstice (cause I ain’t heard it) for January 1979, Magic Lantern Days for Red Cow, and East Ender’s Wives for Grist for the Malady Mill.

Oh shoot. Messes of Men is amazing too. So is Carousels. And Bear’s Vision. And...

 

Even though I've had 3 years with it, it doesn't feel long enough to accurately place PH songs in any list. Idk why really, but all of those songs are still growing on me to this day. PH is my second favorite mwY album.

 

i mean me putting "winter solstice" in there also goes for the alt. version on the EP

 

But what’s really going on here?

 

Ah!

 

I didn't include anything new yet but I think Julia and definitely Cities of the Plain would make my list

fun game right!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

All I know is that I'm A Sweater Poorly Knit is my fave song by this band.

The trap I set for you seems to have caught my leg instead.

 

(my list includes nothing from the new record bc... idk it'd considerably rearrange the list and i don't want to brag or make anyone feel bad that they haven't heard the record yet)

 

oh shit actually julia should be on my list

 

I've listened to Julia twice. Really want to jam it on the reg but it'll be worth it to keep it fresh for the lp.

 

She's like a hot cloth on a fevered head
And like a needle she leads me (while I follow like thread)
Tie me up! Untie me! All this wishing I was dead is getting old
It's gettin' old!
... it goes on, but it's old

 

I have listened to Julia.....so many times

 

revised list to account for new record:

flee, thou matadors!
julia
fox's dream of the log flume
new wine, new skins
winter solstice
magic lantern days
c minor
o porcupine
mexican war streets
east enders wives

that sucked even more! where do i put "cities of the plain" and "august 6th" bc they should be in there too!!!!!