Marianas Trench - Haven’t Had Enough Brackets By Now? Join Us! Bracket • Page 4

skin and bones

 

Skin and Bones

 

Alibis

 

Current Score
Skin & Bones - 3
Alibis - 1

 

I'm surprising myself here because of how much Skin and Bones affected me on first listen, but I'm going to go with Alibis.

 

Current Score
Skin & Bones - 3
Alibis - 2

Two hours to go! Anyone else want to get in on this before we move to Masterpiece Theatre?

 

I would probably vote for Alibis, but as the person running the bracket I will only decide a match-up if it is tied. Luckily, Skin & Bones is my second fave on Fix Me and occasionally jostles with Alibis for the title of "fave track"

Final Score
Skin & Bones - 3
Alibis - 2

Congratulations to Skin & Bones - which is moving on to the final Battle Royale.

Masterpiece Theatre coming at you in a few.

 

Round 2 - Masterpiece Theatre

1. Celebrity Status vs. Sing Sing
2. Good to You (feat. Jessica Lee) vs. Good to You (feat. Kate Voegele)
3. All to Myself vs. Masterpiece Theatre II
4. Acadia vs. Cross My Heart
5. Beside You vs. Perfect

Quarterfinals
1 vs. Masterpiece Theatre III
2 vs. 3
4 vs. Masterpiece Theatre I
5 vs. Lover Dearest


This bracket was randomized, so don't @ me if you're upset by some of the brutal match-ups here haha. I also made the executive decision to pit both versions of Good to You against each other, as I am really curious to see which version people prefer (and it makes the overall bracket easier to arrange with 13 songs instead of 12).

LET THE ROUND COMMENCE!

 

1. Celebrity Status (brutal)
2. Good to You (feat. Jessica Lee)
3. All to Myself
4. Cross My Heart
5. Beside You

 

Celebrity Status
Good to You (feat. Kate Voegele)
Masterpiece Theatre II
Acadia
Perfect

 

I love how both of your votes are entirely the opposite, save for Celebrity Status.

That's what I love about this album - it's so damn good and so consistently strong that I feel we won't have too many runaway wins where the losing song in the pair gets no votes.

 

Current Score
Celebrity Status - 2
Sing Sing - 0

Good to You (feat. Jessica Lee) - 1
Good to You (feat. Kate Voegele) - 1

All to Myself - 1
Masterpiece Theatre II - 1

Acadia - 1
Cross My Heart - 1

Beside You - 1
Perfect - 1

 

1. Celebrity Status
2. Good to You (feat. Kate Voegele)
3. All to Myself
4. Acadia
5. Beside You

 

Masterpiece Theater 2 is easily the weakest of the three

 

Current Score
Celebrity Status - 3
Sing Sing - 0

Good to You (feat. Jessica Lee) - 1
Good to You (feat. Kate Voegele) - 2

All to Myself - 2
Masterpiece Theatre II - 1

Acadia - 2
Cross My Heart - 1

Beside You - 2
Perfect - 1

I was expecting more voters for this album haha.

 

@Contender @JediMasterKevo182 @sawhney[rusted]2 @Nate_Johnson @TedSchmosby Get them votes in fam haha

 

1. Celebrity Status vs. Sing Sing
2. Good to You (feat. Jessica Lee) vs. Good to You (feat. Kate Voegele)
3. All to Myself vs. Masterpiece Theatre II
4. Acadia vs. Cross My Heart
5. Beside You vs. Perfect

 

I'm sorry, been crazy both at work and at home last couple weeks, so I didn't find the time to dive in to "Fix Me" (never gave that album a chance). But I'm back for their fantastic trilogy of albums.

1. Celebrity Status vs. Sing Sing
2. Good to You (feat. Jessica Lee) vs. Good to You (feat. Kate Voegele)
3. All to Myself vs. Masterpiece Theatre II (hard one)
4. Acadia vs. Cross My Heart (CMH is the only song I don't really like on this album)
5. Beside You vs. Perfect (Perfect is one of the catchiest songs i know of. Everything about it makes me want to jump, laugh, scream, run, punch, love and cry)

 

So here we go with the trilogies!!!!

This was the second album I got into with the band, after Ever After. Harmony and vocal work on this album is incredible and I really wish I got into the band earlier than I did. Masterpiece is shy of a masterpiece, since I think the slow songs really bog down the pacing of the album, and just aren't great. Good thing they worked out the kinks for Ever After though, since I think that albums as close to a 10 as possible.

1. Celebrity Status vs. Sing Sing
2. Good to You (feat. Jessica Lee) vs. Good to You (feat. Kate Voegele) - This is my least favorite song on the album lol
3. All to Myself vs. Masterpiece Theatre II - Masterpiece is great, but doesn't work as well as a song on its own
4. Acadia vs. Cross My Heart
5. Beside You vs. Perfect

 

Celebrity Status

Good to You (Feat. Jessica Lee)

Masterpiece Theatre II

Acadia

Perfect

 

Two and a half hours to go!

Current Score
Celebrity Status - 7
Sing Sing - 0

Good to You (feat. Jessica Lee) - 3
Good to You (feat. Kate Voegele) - 4

All to Myself - 5
Masterpiece Theatre II - 2

Acadia - 6
Cross My Heart - 1

Beside You - 2
Perfect - 5

 

My votes
Sing Sing - I adore this song, it's a ton of fun and I can't let it go completely without love. Celebrity Status is a great song, and was up there with my fave tracks on the album to start, but over time it has lost its appeal and I don't listen to it much anymore.

Good to You (feat. Kate Voegele) - I prefer Kate's harmonies with Josh to those of Jessica.

All to Myself - I love both songs, but All to Myself is a great standalone song and Masterpiece Theatre II only works well in the context of the full album.

Acadia - One of my fave songs on the album, so easy choice.

Perfect - Hardest match-up this round, I think. But Perfect is a gem and I had to give it the vote.

 

Final Score
Celebrity Status - 7
Sing Sing - 1

Good to You (feat. Jessica Lee) - 3
Good to You (feat. Kate Voegele) - 5

All to Myself - 6
Masterpiece Theatre II - 2

Acadia - 7
Cross My Heart - 1

Beside You - 2
Perfect - 6


Quarterfinals
Celebrity Status vs. Masterpiece Theatre III

Good to You (feat. Kate Voegele) vs. All to Myself

Acadia vs. Masterpiece Theatre I

Perfect vs. Lover Dearest

 

Some truly brutal match-ups this round. Happy voting everyone!

 

Masterpiece Theatre III
All to Myself
Masterpiece Theatre I
Perfect