Manchester Orchestra - The Million Masks of God (April 30, 2021) Album • Page 39

gonna risk my entire reputation rn and say I kinda dislike "April Fool", one of my least favourite songs they've put on an album possibly. yes, I'm a bad person

anyway I couldn't possibly pick 3 favourites from each album. what am I made of steel?

 

I'm gonna tally all these up at the end, btw.

 

Whoever said that Bed Head is reminiscent of Silversun Pickups - I think it was a few of you - thank you!! I listened to their debut album years ago and wasn’t a fan, didn’t return to them later on. But after your comments, I played the SSPU record that got some mentions (Neck of the Woods) and loved every second of it.

 

Colly Strings
Wolves at Night
I Can Barely Breathe

Shake It Out
I Can Feel a Hot One
The River

Leave It Alone
Apprehension
Mighty

Every Stone
Choose You
Girl Harbor

The Grocery
The Maze
The Silence

 

where
breathe
ticket

teeth
feel
river

deer
pensacola
breaks

girl
ocean
stone

lead
grocery
wolf

 

i was first to do so, you're welcome. i am brave and strong.

 

this post was infuriating and it had nothing to do with the choices

 

im a busy man

 

Your bravery shall be remembered

 

Like a Virgin:
Wolves at Night
Where Have You Been
I can Barely Breathe

METN:
Shake it Out
In My Teeth
The Only One

Simple Math:
Pensacola
Virgin
Apprehension

Cope:
Choose You
Every Stone
All That I Really Wanted

Black Mile: (easily the hardest picks for me)
The Moth
The Alien
The Grocery

 

ILAVLAC:
I Can Barely Breathe
Where Have You Been
Colly Strings

METN:
Shake It Out
Pride
The River

SM:
Pale Black Eye
Leave It Alone
Apprehension

Cope:
The Ocean
Cope
After the Scripture (if it counts, if not - Every Stone)

ABMTTS:
The Moth
The Grocery
The Silence

 

ILAVLAC:
Where Have You Been?
I Can Barely Breathe
Colly Strings

METN:
Shake It Out
I Can Feel a Hot One
Pride
(kills me to leave off "I've Got Friends" or "The River")

Simple Math:
Simple Math
Leave It Alone
Pale Black Eye

Cope/Hope:
Girl Harbor
Top Notch
The Mansion

ABMTTS:
The Silence
The Wolf
The Gold
(kills me to leave off the rest of the album)

Top 5 All Time:

The Silence
Bed Head (yup, already)
Simple Math
Shake It Out
I Can Feel a Hot One

 

Like a Virgin:

Wolves at Night
Don’t Let Them See You Cry
Colly Strings

METN:

The Only One
I Can Feel a Hot One
The River

Simple Math:

Virgin
Simple Math
Leave it Alone

Cope:

Top Notch
The Ocean
All That I Really Wanted

Black Mile:

The Grocery
The Gold
The Alien

 

The problem with only listing your top 3 songs from every album is that it doesn’t allow you to give a shout out to I Know How To Speak.

 

I did anyway. It’s my #1 Manchester song

 

You Know How to Rank

 

Like a Virgin:

Sleeper 1972
Don’t Let Them See You Cry
Colly Strings

METN:

The Only One
My Friend Marcus
Everything to Nothing

Simple Math:

Pensacola
Virgin
Simple Math

Cope:

Every Stone
Girl Harbor
Choose You

Black Mile:

The Silence
Lead, SD
The Gold

 

This is fun

I'm Like a Virgin:
1. Colly Strings
2. Where Have You Been?
3. I Can Barely Breathe

Mean Everything to Nothing:
1. Shake It Out
2. Pride
3. The River

Simple Math:
1. Simple Math
2. Leave It Alone
3. Pensacola

COPE:
1. Every Stone
2. Top Notch
3. The Ocean

A Black Mile to the Surface:
1. The Grocery
2. The Silence
3. Lead, SD

 

Virgin:
1. Colly Strings
2. I Can Barely Breathe
3. Wolves at Night

METN:
1. I Can Feel a Hot One
2. Pride
3. Shake it Out

Simple Math:
1. Apprehension
2. Virgin
3. April Fool

Cope:
1. Cope
2. Top Notch
3. Girl Harbor

ABMTTS:
1. The Silence
2. The Wolf
3. The Grocery

All Time: (I’m gonna be that asshole and use this area to include Nobody Sings Anymore songs)
1. Colly Strings
2. I Can Barely Breathe
3. The Procession
4. Wolves at Night
5. Girl with Broken Wings

 

Okay okay I needed something to help me procrastinate from starting work anyways lol

Now That You’re Home
Where Have You Been
Colly Strings

Shake It Out
Everything to Nothing
The River

Pensacola
Leave it Alone
Apprehension

Top Notch
Every Stone
Trees

The Maze
The Grocery
The Silence

Shoutout to I Know How To Speak

 

Was really into Mean everything to nothing and remember being disappointed at simple math when it came out. Never gave cope or hope a chance. Love Bed Head and a black mile to the surface. I don’t know what I was thinking because with a relisten this week, they all clicked.

What’s the general ranking consensus in this thread these days? About to dive back in

 

ILAVLAC

Where Have You Been?
I Can Barely Breathe
Wolves at Night

METN

Shake it Out
Everything to Nothing
I Can Feel a Hot One

SM

Leave it Alone
Pensacola
Apprehension

Cope

Every Stone
Trees
After the Scripture

ABMTTS

The Silence
The Gold
The Wolf

Bad Books I

Please Move
You Wouldn't Have to Ask
You're a Mirror I Cannot Avoid

Bad Books II

It Never Stops
42
Petite Mort

Bad Books III

Army
UFO
Myths Made Plain

RAGC - The Bitter End

Like Lions Do
Love, Come and Save Me
I'm Not Ready to Forgive You

RAGC - The Eventually Home

I Was A Cage
I Am Vampire
What a Pity

RAGC - The Church and the Good Thief

We Were Made Out of Lightning
Blame
Rotten Black Root

 

Colly Strings
Sleeper 1972
Golden Ticket

Pride
I’ve Got Friends
I Can Feel a Hot One

Simple Math
Pale Black Eye
Apprehension

See It Again
Top Notch
The Mansion

Lead, SD
The Grocery
The Wolf

 

colly
now that you're home
alive

pride
I can feel a hot one
ETN

SM
Pale black eye
apprehension

top notch
every stone
cope

the silence
the maze
the wolf

 

The Neighborhood is Bleeding
Golden Ticket
Colly Strings

The Only One
I Can Feel a Hot One
Tony the Tiger

Deer
Pale Black Eye
Leave It Alone

Girl Harbor
The Ocean
All That I Really Wanted

The Maze
The Grocery
The Gold