Lucy Dacus - Forever is a Feeling (March 28, 2025) • Page 9

I really like this. She’s such a good lyricist and a solid songwriter. I miss the rock of the first 2 albums but this is still great.

 

I liked it…didn’t love it, but definitely potential to grow. Her voice is so soothing, it would be nice for a few different tempos. Most Wanted Man and Lost Time a killer way to close the album though. Really good.

 

my first listen of this was… fine? which is pretty disappointing after how much i loved her first three records. i kind of agree with the pitchfork review that it feels strangely subdued and docile for a record covering which i think is a really beautiful love story. i also think that, while there are plenty of lines and passages that made me feel some shit, there are way more clunky lyrics than i’d expect from her.

i expect it to open up more on repeated listens, but i’m feeling underwhelmed right now.

 

those two + limerence were definitely my favorites

 

I would also add For Keeps.

 

Out of all the boygenius members she’s the one I gravitate towards the least, but I wouldn’t call this boring.

 

I like this, don’t love it. Feels like it peters out around the Hozier collab and I tuned out a little. The first half of the album is really good though, and I love Talk

 

Her voice is so good but I’m so bored. On best guess at the moment and it’s the first song I will 100% come back to.

 

“Talk” and “Forever” are the ones

 

Last stretch of songs is nice

 

second listen wasn’t any better than the first, sadly. i think about half the album is pretty good and the other half is fine but feels like it’s missing something.

 

i liked the first half but i'll echo that it loses steam on the back end.

 

I enjoy this a lot - her worst out of her disco but still good

 

I’ve had it on in the background while I read and do enjoy it. Currently enjoying Come Out

 

Idunno how yall aren’t vibing with Most Wanted Man, so good

 

last 2 songs on this are unreal

 

Idunno if you guys have done a quality headphones listen, but the production on this is immaculate

 

do we know the writing/producing/performing credits on this?

 

opening up for me a little on third listen. I have never loved any of her solo records in full, and this probably isn't any different for me, but I still think it's Good. her best songs for me are the ones with a little more force so I definitely agree that she seems to be leaning away from her strongest impulses here. I also agree that the production is really detailed and pretty and warrants a more focused listen. the title track is particularly nice in that regard. A lot of the first half is great. I don't really like "Come Out" or "Bullseye." "Talk" rules.

 

t/t is my favourite song I've heard this year so far lol

 

title track is pretty easily my least favorite