Lorde Cancels Israel Concert Date Amid Protests

Discussion in 'Article Discussion' started by Melody Bot, Dec 24, 2017.

  1. Melody Bot

    Your friendly little forum bot. Staff Member

  2. Wharf Rat

    I know a little something you won't ever know Prestigious

    Well done
     
    AshlandATeam likes this.
  3. Wharf Rat

    I know a little something you won't ever know Prestigious

    Victor Eremita and AshlandATeam like this.
  4. St. Nate

    We were just talkin' bout the Jesus. Prestigious

    Dope
     
  5. janexo

    Regular

    good......but she should also cancel her Russian dates
     
    Jonathan, kait_whiteside and Brent like this.
  6. somethingwitty

    Regular

    Kinda confused on this...so shes skipping Israel due to their policies towards Palestine...but shes completely ok,playong the US even though their policies have become equally atrocious under Trump...
     
  7. Wharf Rat

    I know a little something you won't ever know Prestigious

    There is a targeted boycott initiated on the request of Palestinian groups which hopes to emulate the success of a similar boycott in South Africa. The boycott is not a principled stance, it is a tactic hoping to achieve a goal. No goal can be achieved by boycotting the world hegemon
     
    Victor Eremita, St. Nate, Tim and 2 others like this.
  8. Neon Light

    rage and love

    Pretty poor to announce a show and then cancel it. She had to know there would be backlash from some of her fans as there is towards almost any artist who plays here.
     
    Raku and TJ Wells like this.
  9. Kiana

    Goddamn, man child Prestigious

    People keep bringing up different places she should also be boycotting and it's like they don't understand this. And there's also that attitude of "you're not fixing everything, so what's the point of your action" which is frustrating
     
  10. justin.

    我不在乎

    It's a lot easier to say no to Israel than it is to say no to the US. I'm sure if the $$ was there, her or at least her label would still push for the Israel show to happen.
     
  11. skogsraet

    Trusted Supporter

    I really don’t think it’s just about money. It’s so easy to say pop stars only care about the money, but that completely ignores the political context in which she’s cancelling this show. And I highly doubt the money isn’t there in Israel. It’s good enough for huge acts like Katy Perry and Justin Timberlake (as referenced in the thread linked in the news post) so I think it’s pretty clear this isn’t about money.

    Also, people protest the US all the time. Acts have cancelled shows in NC after the bathroom bill and AZ for anti-immigration bills, off the top of my head. The reason nobody is going to boycott the whole US isn’t just because of money, but because you’d only hurt your own career and fanbase by doing that while drawing really negligible attention to issues.
     
  12. Brent

    Ready When You Are Supporter

    She's bad at planning.
     
    Raku likes this.
  13. justin.

    我不在乎

    I hope you’re right. Mega pop stars and labels just have me skeptical.
     
  14. Jonathan

    ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Verified

    Raku, fran.182 and kait_whiteside like this.
  15. St. Nate Dec 26, 2017
    (Last edited: Dec 26, 2017)
    St. Nate

    We were just talkin' bout the Jesus. Prestigious

    Wharf Rat likes this.
  16. Wharf Rat

    I know a little something you won't ever know Prestigious

    i liked the part where he talked about "throwing the word apartheid around," thats a good thing to say for sure
     
  17. St. Nate

    We were just talkin' bout the Jesus. Prestigious

    You're being divisive.
     
  18. Jonathan

    ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Verified

    Specifically this part: "I think that it's true to say that the people you'd be denying [the music] are the people who would agree with you and don't necessarily agree with their government."

    Edit: it's Godrich's quote but I like it.
     
    Raku likes this.
  19. St. Nate

    We were just talkin' bout the Jesus. Prestigious

    Ah I see.

    Just seems that being denied the privilege of seeing *insert music act* is minuscule in the context of said disagreement that Godrich mentions but does not go into detail in, but denies people's human rights.

    Do you think that statement works with something like say Apartheid South Africa?
     
  20. Jonathan

    ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Verified

    That seems like an opinion which hinges on how you feel about the conflict with Israel and Palestine. I won't be going down that rabbit hole, so I respectfully decline the invite. In my experience, it's usually puts people's thinly veiled anti-semitism or anti-arabism on display, and I'd prefer not to see that here. I'm neutral when it comes to Palestine and Israel. Admittedly my knowledge of the Apartheid is limited, so without doing more research I can't answer your question, but based on what I do know, I don't believe the two are accurate comparisons either.

    I don't believe people should be punished for their government's actions, same goes for Russia and the United States. There's plenty of people who don't agree with what people in power are doing. When Maroon 5 and Ringo Star cancelled their gigs in North Carolina in protest of the bathroom bill, it was easier for me to rally behind since my mind was made up on that issue, but in hindsight I feel bad for people who live there and didn't support that bill. I do, however, support the artist's right to choose and make that decision, even if I don't agree with it. Same goes for Lorde here, even if my original reply didn't mention that.
     
    Raku and fran.182 like this.
  21. St. Nate

    We were just talkin' bout the Jesus. Prestigious

    I think this hardly qualifies as punishment.

    I encourage you to learn more on the situation.

    http://m.jpost.com/Israel-News/Mand...t-Israel-is-the-worst-apartheid-regime-515397

    Anyway, a statement like Radiohead’s only does damage to Palestinians in that it makes fans who miss out on their favorite band victims when in the full context of the situation and just in general, they are not.
     
    Wharf Rat likes this.
  22. Jonathan

    ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Verified

    Raku and FreshnessExpired like this.
  23. mercury

    modern-day offspring fanatic Supporter

    Theoretically yeah, it would be ideal if political issues were sorted out in isolation from culture/social life/etc... but that's not how politics works. Nobody wants to "punish" others for happening to live in a country whose government they disagree with - the point is to try & force the government to hear a message that they're otherwise ignoring. Citizens losing access to a concert is an unfortunate (but necessary) side effect of trying to achieve that goal.
     
    Jonathan, St. Nate and Wharf Rat like this.
  24. St. Nate

    We were just talkin' bout the Jesus. Prestigious

    Well technically you declined then followed it up with a statement on the situation so...
     
    skogsraet and Wharf Rat like this.
  25. Jonathan

    ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Verified

    You're clearly looking to argue, best of luck to you.
     
    Raku and FreshnessExpired like this.