Lady Gaga - Joanne (October 21, 2016) Album • Page 3

Key change is bad, I like the rest.

 

if anyone needs a link

 

Not a horrible song, just a weak comeback after 3 years. Her voice definitely needed to be sharper to sell that hook better.

 

pretty much how i feel.

 

Yeah that chorus isn't too great, she def needed to go higher or something on it. It's not terrible per se but definitely not up to her usual standards. It'll probably grow on me a bit, I like the parts outside the chorus right now.

 

Man, I thought the combo of Gaga, Ronson, Bloodpop and Parker would be incredible. But this just sounds like her singing over some Tame Impala leftovers.

 

outside of the guitar this is like, all bloodpop

 

Man this was disappointing. With Parker being involved I had high hopes.

 

Yeah considering the collaborators I had high hopes for this

 

That key change tho

 

i thought it was good! dig it a lot more than her last two albums.

 

I actually don't like this at all and I'm upset.

 

such an abrasive chorus. so lackluster :\

 

I liked this a lot more hearing it on the radio


Lady Gaga's New Album Features a Duet with Florence Welch

 

I like it

 

I listened again and somehow it got worse

 

Wait Josh Homme played guitar on this?

 

horrible

 

Definitely the most exciting part about this song. Pitchfork (lol) came hard with the snark on this one too.

 

This is great lol
Slacking About Maybe Reviewing Lady Gaga's “Perfect Illusion” | Pitchfork

 

The best thing I've read on Pitchfork in a long time.

 

A new leaked track, "Freakshow" is much better

Lady Gaga - Freakshow - Jams - Daily New Jams

 

I think perfect illusion would actually be good if not for the song ruining key change. that bridge could have transitioned into something else that's actually interesting and not jarring in the worst way. I think the reason the key change feels so horrible is because the build is so sudden and doesn't really build TO anything, the song starts out at 100 so them trying to take it to a higher level just feels silly as hell

 

Pretty sure that's Ronson on the guitar.

 

Ronson, Homme & Parker