All 5 Circa albums are incredible one of my favorite bands ever. A Circa Thursday JEW tour would be so sweet
I wish I liked Circa more. Every time I listen to OLG it hurts that it's the only album of theirs I really love. It's so good though, easily my second favourite Anthony music, I might even prefer it to Saosin's self titled now which would have been crazy to me like five years ago.
Give BSN another shot maybe? It and OLG and Juturna are like a 3 way tie for my favorite Circa record. They are kind of a weird band though so I get why you might not like the other stuff
Sigur Rós and Thrice round out my top 5, but ask me for my top 5 in a few months and Thrice might not be there anymore. The #5 spot changes frequently haha
Circa is a very consistent band. I don't love any of their albums, but like all of them. Blue Sky Noise and Violent Waves are my two favorites though
BSN has some great songs on it but as a whole I find it just solid. It's definitely my second favourite though, "Get Out" and "Fever Dreams" are wonderful.
1. Jimmy Eat World 2. Circa Survive 3. Thursday 4. Sigur Rós 5. Thrice 6. Deafheaven 7. Pianos Become The Teeth 8. Moving Mountains 9. The 1975 10. Caspian I did it