The list isn't that bad, it's wild and I'm surprised at Goodbye Cool World over Vacation (and saying to skip "Campaign For A Better Weekend" because what) but Get Warmer, Adults, and Scrambles are all top tier and I think swapping GCW and Vacation makes it pretty good
This is the part that made me most mad haha. I love all these albums like my children but anything except Vacation or Scrambles at #1 is crazy to me.
Scrambles is my #1 but Get Warmer is my wife's #1 and she is who got me obsessed with BTMI! so I definitely respect it. Those 2, Adults, and Vacation are all 10/10s in my heart so anyone can do any order with those and I'll be happy.
I go back and forth on if I think WORRY or Vacation is Jeff's best so seeing it at 5 knocked me over haha
You’re better off reading how Jeff personally ranked them Rank Your Records: Jeff Rosenstock Rates Every Bomb the Music Industry! Album
yeah look I love the whole discog but the others can be pretty inconsistent. Get Warmer for example has some of my favourite songs he ever wrote and then a bunch I never listen to at all he was absolutely on one with that closing run and Vacation is one of the best albums in the genre