It's got some great tracks and I love the way it sounds but I agree it's not as good as Purgatory or the slew of unreleased/lightly released songs from the pre-Purgatory era. I think he's got a whole hell of a lot left in the tank though, he's nowhere near having peaked. And his live show is very very good.
I've only ever been a casual Isbell listener, but this was really good on my first listen and I love it on my second. My only complaint is that I wish "What've I Done . . ." was a couple minutes shorter and he repeated the chorus less (like during the guitar solo). I still really like the song, I just need a radio edit of it.
"What've I Done To Help" has only grown on me more and more, and I already liked the song a lot to begin with.
Isbell interview on men in blazers podcast (typically a soccer podcast) https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/men-in-blazers-05-13-20-with-jason-isbell/id908407811?i=1000474485003
Thought the Pitchfork review was one of the fairer, level-headed write-ups they've given him. Pleasantly surprised
I only listened to one of the songs released so far, I think maybe the opener? It was fine but I certainly wasn't blown away. But it's Isbell so I still have high hopes I'll enjoy the album.
I'm definitely pumped, the comments in here already, along with all the press, and the singles have me really excited.
If it was the opener that song is quite different than the rest of the album and I also didnt really love it first couple listens outside the album context
Someone described What've I Done to Help" as the bridge from The Nashville Sound to this album, and I think that describes it perfectly. Definitely an outlier.
yea I'll change my mind by next week let's be honest but it's what I'm feeling on this particular afternoon
"Cover Me Up" was my top song of the 2010s, so that's a very high bar. Nudging out "Dress Blues" for the five slot is a big accomplishment though.
"Running With Our Eyes Closed" has REALLY grown on me as I've kept listening to the album over the last few days, to the point where I can't even hear why the hell I was saying I thought it was slightly weaker than the songs around it on my first few listens. This album is fantastic. I'm getting to the point where the songs I had already heard don't stick out to me and I can just listen to the whole album smoothly.