This article has been imported from chorus.fm for discussion. All of the forum rules still apply. J.J. Abrams has signed on for a live action remake of the popular anime Your Name. MTV reports: While anime fans have a reason to be skeptical following the recent unsuccessful live-action remakes of Ghost in the Shell and Death Note, it should hopefully ease some fears knowing that Genki Kawamura, who produced the anime, will also serves as a producer on this film. Expand - View Original
I'm typically all for remakes, but not this one :x But I guess there's no stopping it at this point - I just hope it's halfway decent. And if you haven't seen the original yet, watch it. It honestly only just came out not all that long ago.
This was my favorite movie of 2016. I think this will turn out to be garbage but, without spoiling anything, JJ Abrams/Heisserer are probably the best people to attempt an adaptation at this.
Honestly, I'd be okay with somebody like Zendaya and Tyler James Williams as the leads and have it take place in a vibrant and bright city like New Orleans. But I understand that Japanese actors are incredibly underrepresented in American media so they should definitely keep it as a Japanese cast.
No, yeah I absolutely agree. Appropriating/rewriting it to the culture is understandable. But, white washing Ghost in The Shell level is a bad idea haha
The pacing felt kind of rushed to me. I don't think I was able to care about the characters enough to have a large emotional reaction. I still liked it but I'd rank it as my third favorite by Shinkai
weird, i disagree completely. the movie completely overwhelmed me with emotions, in the best way. i was taken for a loop so many times i came out of the movie just totally struck. saw it again two days after and the impact was just as strong.
Yeah idk I was totally hyped for it too, hes one of my favorite anime directors. I'll probably try watching it again at some point especially if an adaption is coming out.
But like, what can be done in the live action movie to make it better that wasn't already done in the animated film?
the first time i saw it i actually missed the first five minutes of the movie so i missed the intro, i was stunned when i saw it the second time and it gave so much away, haha. definitely lucked out in my timing
Yeah...like I'm okay with the idea of live action adaptation if it's done right...but the original hasn't even had time to breathe hahaha, it's barely over a year old.
it's like the Martyrs remake. remakes should only exist if they offer a meaningful variation on the cultural lens, and even then only after enough time has passed that watching the original movie won't work for some reason