I wonder if it really was supposed to be a secret and Kaitlyn fucked it up :P That's what you get for trusting a bird.
For a long time I thought that Charlie actually got Bad New tattooed on his arm because of that one joke but apparently he just puts it on for every episode lol
My friend did a homemade tattoo of Bad New on himself lmao, so great when people see it and he has to explain it each & every time that it's from IASIP; a show that 99% of the people he encounters have never heard of