This is easily the strongest record they’ve put out since Enemy.. might even be their best period tbh. Picking this up from my record store today!
I just finished a FYS discography run, and honestly, I learned that I don't really like this band haha. This album is SUPER interesting though, it surprised me, lots of new things from them and a lot I enjoyed
RODT is a fun album and they put on a clinic with EOTW. ISWSOF is a clear miss even if the ideas are there. Self titled feels like the one that set them on track to become the band they are today but honestly I was pretty out on them/this sound by 2015. I was skeptical about Brain Pain at first but it won me over eventually
RODT was on heavy rotation in college for me, but then I didn’t really like anything they’d done until a handful of songs from Brain Pain. But love this new album, definitely their best.
I remember RODT coming out as well, ha. Still solid but it hasn’t aged the best. Definitely stuck in the 00s sound. I really enjoyed their covers album as well and pretty much all of EOTW, but everything after dropped off for me. Sounds like a need to give this album a spin.
After playing this new record all weekend - I think my current ranking is: Enemy > Analysis Paralysis > Brain Pain > Rise > S/T > ISWSOF I think all their EPs are largely forgettable aside from a few tracks like Tread Lightly ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I’ve never really liked GDIH the song, but I like that EP a lot otherwise. At the time it came out I would’ve called it their best release too. Still not convinced I’ve ever seen a more accurate “return to form” album in this scene, it was like ISWSOF never even happened
I adored RODT at the time, but most of it very much feels like a relic of the past to me at this point lol
I think this is my favorite album by them. It’s somehow heavier, and poppier than usual at the same time, and it works very well.
I agree RODT feels very of the time but as I get older I find that more of a feature than a bug. No one was doing it like them at that point, they really stood out - and when I need something that sounds like that now, there’s nothing else that hits the same. If it was problematic or something I would not feel that way
RODT would benefit from a EOTW style re-record. But yes those songs are very late 2000s scene sounding lol