Foo Fighters - But Here We Are (June 2nd, 2023) • Page 34

Very uninterested in this narrative.

 

I’m out

 

Cameron is Josh Freese. Confirmed!

 

lmao

 

i did not read the rest of the thread and thought matt cameron was taking over and was like hey man leave some 90s bands for the rest of us

 

Tom Delonge is in

 

At least Josh has a sense of humor about his exit, unlike that perpetual crybaby William Goldsmith.

 

Yeah William still seems pretty bitter about it. But I kind of see why since Dave may have had something to do with a new SDRE album being canned

 

This is news to me lol what's all that about?

 

https://www.spin.com/2018/12/sunny-day-real-estate-william-goldsmith-dave-grohl-unreleased-album/

 

I’d have to find the quote, but basically, IIRC, William said that SDRE was working on
A new album at Studio 606 sometime in 2010/2011 but it was completely scrapped because they weren’t getting the support they wanted and Nate pretty much ghosted them when they were set to discuss how to go forward. He accused Dave of not being supportive of Nate doing SDRE which is why Nate bailed. They haven’t spoken since

EDIT: Someone beat me to it lol

 

Damn, Dave has lost a lot of goodwill lately but Goldsmith comes off like a giant baby here

 

I don’t blame him for being upset over how the album was canned, but some of his wording is so unnecessarily theatrical lmao

 

Curious if SDRE does a new album soon since their reunion tours seem to be doing well.

 

Colour and the Shape was released 28 years ago today.

 

Goldsmith is absolutely a giant baby.

 

Perfect album and their best album.

 

Any of the first three are goated. But TCATS really is something special.

 

I’ve been wondering the same thing. I think new music would need to be in order for them to keep their momentum

2022/23: We’re back!
2024: Diary anniversary
2025: B/C markets we missed
2026: Do it all again but with new music to promote

 

Roll that right into 2027: HIFTBSO anniversary

 

Totally. There is a warmth on the first 3 that has been absent from anything since.

 

The Rising Tide is my favorite

 

TCATS is one of a handful of albums I consider perfect front to back.

 

Echoing that TCATS is a perfect album

 

I prefer S/T and TINLTL but it's definitely one of their best