Final Four: (7) Jimmy Eat World - Futures vs. (27) Weezer - Weezer (The Blue Album) Bracket • Page 6

The part that makes it the most fun is I mean it.

 

oasis is a better band than both these bands combined and they’re not even a top 5 band for me

 

I would never doubt your sincerity!

 

Well now you're just lying.

 

Look, I don’t like Electable either, but it doesn’t have creepy lyrics

 

Pretty sure I said it in one of the other threads that I haven't heard enough Weezer to really have an opinion on if they're better or worse instrumentalists than anyone but I do want to say Zach Lind sets as great a foundation as a drummer anyone could hope to have. He never gets in the way of the song but has a great ear for little flourishes and details he can add that elevates everything

 

Zach and Pat are both great and excellent examples of effective rock drumming

 

nah lol. i’m not. they’re just the most entertaining to talk about. probably 7 for me.

 

yeah zach was the one i was closest to giving the edge to but pat is also a very good drummer

neither band really puts the bass to proper use

 

The judges are going to need to see the full list to make a decision.

 

i feel like i’ve posted it before but maybe not. also depends on if we’re only counting bands or solo musicians as well

1. David Bowie
2. Bob Dylan
3. Black Sabbath
4. The Stooges
5. Nirvana
6. Nine Inch Nails (if you include trent stuff outside of the band they go up a spot)
7. Oasis
8. Wilco
9. Velvet Underground
10. The Band

 

then some combo of radiohead, beastie boys, fugazi, beatles and dino jr

 

Bad Religion is my favorite band

 

they’re fucking great!

 

It is

 

i’m just wondering how much jim paid y’all to post

i’ll say i will steal you back is a good song for some cash

 

Facts

 

I'm shook! I honestly never would have guessed you'd rank Nirvana over the Brothers Gallagher.

 

"I Will Steal You Back" is still better than anything on Green.

 

I didn't realize Phaynes was every cool dad

 

Jim was offering to pay us? Fuck, I’ve been posting for free all this time

 

Man, if Jim paid me for my Jimmy Eat World takes, I'd be a very wealthy person.

 

Billy Joel
Chad Perrone (inc. Averi)
Prince
Bruce Springsteen
Andrew McMahon (inc. various projects)
Mary Chapin Carpenter
Jonah Matranga (inc. various projects)
The Beatles
Dessa
Dan Fogelberg

Then I dunno. Pick from The Hold Steady, Coheed and Cambria, Jimmy Eat World, Motion City Soundtrack, Lou Reed/VU, Bob Dylan, Metallica, Nina Simone, Taylor Swift, Phil Collins, ELO, Meg and Dia, Lights, Peter Paul and Mary

I'm sure I'm forgetting a bunch

 

again, just show me the pay stub and i’ll debase myself too

 

I only speak my truth.