I think Garrett should have been able to keep the money. Even though I hated him, it seems like not giving him the money kind of undermines the entire premise of the show. That being said, any charity deserves it a lot more than he does.
i get that argument. also it’s 100% fuck him and seeing the realization go over his face he still wasn’t getting paid was worth it
Honestly I think the idea of it being 100K split evenly if you pick the nice guy and 100K for the f-boy to determine if it's split up if you choose them was the perfect solution. Adding the extra element of taking it away from Garrett at the end kind of ruins it. Again, fuck him all day, he deserves nothing, but Sarah made her choice and that was the point on the game. Garrett's right...He signed up for a GAME show called F-Boy Island and he played the game the way he intended to from day one until the end... and for better or worse, he "won".
Also, I liked the element of the "mansplain" tell all at the end, but I feel like keeping every guy around until the end of the show just for that was a little weird. I feel like they need to add something else for the eliminated guys. Give them an opportunity to battle back, or for the woman to choose to bring one of them back at the end in leiu of the money or one of their final two guys or something. Or maybe have sabateurs amongst the group that are spreading mis-information about the guys (maybe there was some of that anyway)
it’ll be interesting for s2 if it’s renewed. you aren’t gonna have someone like garrett if they know what’s gonna happen to them at the end
Conflicted about the ending. Obviously a charity is the best option but i kinda think Garrett should’ve gotten to keep it. I really hated the two Jarreds. OG was a weirdo and no one liked him. New was a douchebag. That “how’s my dick taste” line at the end really sealed it for me. Casey was a dork but I think I liked him more by the end of it. Was shocked CJ didn’t pick him. The other two second place guys were nothings, no real feelings for either of them
really repeatedly just kept make me think of "I'm not a piece of shit, I can change" whenever casey would speak