Father John Misty - Pure Comedy (April 7, 2017) Album • Page 9

Discussion in 'Music Forum' started by brandon_260, Jan 23, 2017.

  1. imthegrimace

    Grimace Lives Supporter

    Never got into him until this week but I'm loving the songs that have already been released from this album and his last album. What's the reason for people hating him?
     
  2. Surfwax

    bring on the major leagues Supporter

    Most of what he says in interviews/press stuff in general is over the top smartest guy in the room stuff from way out in left field; he wears this very specific brand of quirkiness like a badge of honor and it comes across (for some, myself included) annoying at best and condescendingly at worst. If it's all a joke he's kinda just overdoing it and if it's what he actually thinks it's a bit self aggrandizing.

    I think his music's fine but the people I know that love him reaally love him and fair or not for me that just makes the whole above more off putting.
     
  3. imthegrimace

    Grimace Lives Supporter

    Thank you for the reply. Much appreciated.
     
  4. I'll touch on this more in a longform review, but I do feel like the snarkiness of it all is largely more absent here than it was on I Love You, Honeybear. Like, people either love or hate that album for the same reason. And there's still humorous lines here, the flowery imagery and language is there, but to me, this album feels a lot more serious and a lot less mean-spirited at other peoples' expenses. But I also don't think that's enough to change minds as his public persona has remained virtually the same.
     
    Wall Of Arms and coleslawed like this.
  5. brandon_260

    Trusted Prestigious

    I worry that because of his other albums and the persona that went with them people won't see this album as sincere though.
     
    Aaron Mook likes this.
  6. OhTheWater

    Let it run Supporter

    I still haven't listened to this, I probably will this week, but he's not doing much to squash the snark persona when the lead single is Pure Comedy and contains lines like:

    Oh, their religions are the best
    They worship themselves yet they're totally obsessed
    With risen zombies, celestial virgins, magic tricks, these unbelievable outfits
    And they get terribly upset
    When you question their sacred texts
    Written by woman-hating epileptics

    I get what he's going for, fine, but I don't fully bite on most of his commentary. The "zombie" line is straight off of a Hot Topic shirt or a hack comedian's first draft.
     
    truelovewaits likes this.
  7. vidiviciveni

    Trusted

    I like him as a songwriter, find his persona a little obnoxious, but mostly I find his writing has become a little too theatric. I really enjoyed the vibe of Fear Fun, but since this his songs have become too elaborate and long-winded to really catch my ear. I was really rooting for his SNL performance but it just seemed out of place.
     
  8. carrytheweird

    www.nrdc.org

    He's got a very strong-headed personality, and also used to be a little overboard with his social network commentary. But personally, more than half the time I don't disagree with his views so it effects me, and some like me, none.
     
    Aaron Mook likes this.
  9. cherrywaves

    Trusted

    I will never forget the meme I saw that just said "FJM is just Michael Buble for people who shop at Trader Joe's"
     
  10. contra11mundum

    I hate spoilers. Supporter

    I've always kind of thought of him as the (former version of) Stephen Colbert, but with music.
     
  11. jpmalone4

    Stay Lucky Supporter

    This is accurate, I got in trouble once in (Catholic) high school for saying Jesus was a zombie during a religion class.
     
  12. AngryMan

    Regular

    Isn't that the point though? To break it down to basic, stupid terms and question how someone could believe in something so unbelievable? It's not supposed to be some biting critique.
     
    Transient_Hymn likes this.
  13. kbeef2

    Trusted Supporter

     
    Aaron Mook and zmtr like this.
  14. Kyle is hk

    Not Kyle Shanahan Prestigious

  15. Yeesh, that interview reads like Morrissey doing a Morrissey impression
     
    AngryMan likes this.
  16. OhTheWater

    Let it run Supporter

    This guy sucks!



    (Say it like Silicon Valley)
     
    Kyle is hk and imthesheriff like this.
  17. zmtr

    89 enjoyer

    Thought the Paste interview was great.

    What he's doing for this tour cycle seems like it's gonna rule
     
  18. Transient_Hymn

    Somebody Turn the Neon Down Supporter

    Love his schtick
    He is unabashedly outrageous and it's refreshing....even if I don't agree with most of what he says. ha
     
  19. DeathOrGlory

    Just a friendly reminder

    The Paste piece is definitely a better interview. It actually gets to the human beneath the character.
     
  20. zmtr

    89 enjoyer

    All 3 of these are great but this one is the best

     
  21. zmtr

    89 enjoyer





    wouldn't mind a whole "generic pop" album
     
  22. zmtr

    89 enjoyer

    Ok 3 is actually my favorite. This shit is so good hahaha
     
  23. jpmalone4

    Stay Lucky Supporter

    Damn I was busy traveling last few days and didn't get to hear those before he took them down.
     
  24. AngryMan

    Regular

    They can still be found on youtube
     
    jpmalone4 likes this.