Fall Out Boy - So Much (For) Stardust (March 24,2023) Band • Page 19

Exactly two months away!

 

if someone's favorite FOB album is Mania or AB/AP - i have absolutely no issue with that, like what you like lol its just so silly when folks come in and just drop silly shit like "the last 3 albums are trash"

just patently false shit lol

 

That kind of critique is never very helpful. I think it’s fine if old fans don’t like the newer albums as well. Like you said, you like what you like. While there are still a lot of similarities, I can see how the sonic choices could work for or against some listeners on the newer albums. Everyone’s music palette is different.

 

This one's mine.

 

I’ve seen better

 

Folie
Cork Tree
Infinity
Save Rock and Roll
Grave
Mania
Beauty / Psycho

idk if I'm happy with this....tttyg and srar are about even. top two are very solid the rest really does move around... i like em all

 

IOH/Folie (this changes on a regular basis)
FUTCT
TTTYG
SRAR
AB/AP
Mania

 

FUTCT
TTTYG
FaD
IOH
SRaR
ABAP
Mania

 

Folie
SRAR
IOH
FUCT
AB/AP
TTTYG
Mania

 

Coulda sworn every living human has already ranked the albums already

 

From Under the Cork Tree
Infinity on High
Take This to Your Grave
Folie a Deux

Save Rock and Roll
AB/AP
Mania

 

Ranking is fun!!

 

Yeah @Jason Tate whats your ranking

 

IOH
FUCT
Folie
AB/AP
TTTYG
M A N I A
SRAR

 

I’m guessing @Jason Tate is something like

IOH
FUTCT
FAD
SRAR
AP/AP
MANIA
TTTYG

 

Somewhere I’ve done that before I’m sure. IOH wouldn’t be first though.

 

If this turns into a "Guess Jason's Ranking" thread, I riot

 

This may have been posted but Pete Wentz himself ranked Fall Out Boy albums for Kerrang in 2021:

Fall Out Boy: Every album ranked from worst to best by… | Kerrang!

 

It was reposted in 2021 but published around MANIA's release. I'm sure this would look different now in hindsight.

 

evening out with your girlfriend
M A N I A
from under the cork tree
take this to your grave
infinity on high
folie
save rock and roll
american beauty / american psycho

 

Oh shit. I didn’t get banned.

 

Save Rock & Roll
Folie A Deux
Infinity On High
From Under The Cork Tree
Take This To Your Grave
Mania
AB/AP