FWIW my top 6 are all "would listen to anytime" haha. Although I'm pretty set on my top 3, I really can't argue against any other arrangement of those albums.
Radical FPU — Low Teens NJA Ex-lives The Big Dirty — Hot Damn! Gutter Phenomenon — — Last Night in Town the ranking for that second tier is pretty arbitrary though
Oasis on twelve lines of cocaine > every other band Maybe today will be the first day of no brutal statements?
FPU Ex-Lives Radical - Low Teens Gutter Phenomenon NJA The Big Dirty - Hot Damn! Last Night In Town My Sadness That This Band Is Now No More
Ex-Lives would be my #1 if the production were more to my liking (more band vs vocals, or maybe it's just a bit thin) but everything from NJA on is tied They were really the most constant band in terms of quality output, within the boundaries of potential experimentation.
The general consensus seems to be that Last Night In Town is the weakest, which honestly I'm not surprised by.
The Big Dirty Radical Ex Lives Low Teens New Junk Aesthetic From Parts Unknown Gutter Phenomenon Hot Damn! Last Night In Town
Some hot takes here, but I think this is my ranking. Adore every one of these records though. Hot Damn! Low Teens Last Night In Town Gutter Phenomenon From Parts Unknown The Big Dirty Ex Lives Radical New Junk Aesthetic
i can only speak for my list but the bottom half of ETID's catalog is still better than most bands' best album