I don't know. I just listened to AS and I'm about halfway through IG and I think I've already noticed more standout songs on IG than AS. It is my first time listening to each and I've been reading stuff online while listening but I haven't been paying attention to any one over the other.
Mine's Similar: Death Star> Instant Gratification > Acceptance Speech > Happiness > DBM > DBMII > Whatever I Say Is Royal Ocean
Fair enough, Deathstar has some of my favorite DGD songs ever. The mid section of the record is so goddamn good.. Hot Water on Wool, Uneasy Hearts, Caviar (love me some Chino), Rock Solid, and Kurt sounds superb on Burning Down the Nicotine Armoire Pt. 2.
lol what. No man, the record is actually much better and all the fans seem to love it. Look at this thread alone. Everyone agrees the record is at least one of the better ones. The one-two punch of Variation/Lost make the record for me. It's just so good.
I tend to forget Chino did a song with DGD, always blows my mind when I remember since I love Deftones and DGD so damn much. Death Star isn't a favorite of mine just cause I feel like they went on to do way better but I feel like if any album could've made DGD a bigger name if even just within the scene, it would've been that album. Guest features and Uneasy Hearts being such a catchy song, it really baffles me that it didn't make more of an impression.
Yeah it sucks they didn't blow up really. The good news is IG was their best selling record yet which is great cause Jon Mess gave an interview prior to the release essentially saying they need to get bigger or they might end in the near future.
I disagree highly. It's nothing special at all, sure, it's Tillian's delivery that makes it so goddamn good. Also Will's guitar work is insane on it. You must have forgot about Uneasy Hearts: "I am a million fucking bucks I am a thousand fucking fucks Your bitch is dead She was hit by a truck WHAT THE FUCK" or maybe NASA.. "Holy fuck I'm depressed Too bad I don't have a pussy to plunge into While I sit here and stomach this Here's a noble prize, lets gamble our demise" The band has always had a plethora of bad lyrics but its the vocal delivery and fantastic/creative musicianship that easily outweighs the bad. So I highly disagree with Lost having the worst lyrics. Also, that still doesn't take away from the fact most, if not all, their fans loved or at least enjoyed Instant Gratification more than others.
I was under the impression that he gave that interview after IG, part of why my hopes are pretty high for DGD8. Regardless, IG charted at 32 on the billboard 200, which is pretty damn impressive for a post hardcore band who, to be fair, doesn't fit so neatly into that genre anymore. I'm real curious what kind of numbers the next one will do
Your definition of what is considered "good" or "deep" lyrics is very narrow. And I'm sorry to see that and can do very little to convince you otherwise.
Weird cause I never said what I consider good or deep lyrics and never said Tillian's lyrics were that. Your reading comprehension must be very narrow and I am sorry to see that.
As someone who stopped listening after Happiness, which should I start with? Acceptance Speech or Instant Gratification?
I kinda only listened to them during DBM but I've been going through their discog this past week and I started at Deathstar and went chronologically. But the album after Happiness is DBM2 which I really thought was not good at all so I would say skip that if you don't care too much and go straight to AS. I think IG is the better Tilian album but you can tell they got more comfortable with him on IG so it's just cool to hear the progress. But I think they're both very good in their own right
IG has some of the bands most popular work IMO. I cannot remember a song bar Uneasy Hearts that is more popular with fans than We Own The Night - gets a huge crowd response live, def one of their best ever songs. They keep progressing, and if they carry on going forward from the IG "vibe" (rather than regress to AS) the next album can only be better!
I listened to DBM2 for the first time in ages earlier and got so bored. Their weakest album by far imo.
Probably AS then IG just to see the progression. AS has some really amazing tracks: "Acceptance Speech", "Strawberry Swisher pt. III", and "The Death of the Robot with Human Hair" are great. IG though is a record you can listen to start to finish. It's boring and you can tell they had no idea what they were doing since Jonny would randomly show up with no lyrics or anything and not be in the best mindset either. Supposedly, Crummet had to help write lyrics for Jonny. I love "Heat Seeking Ghost of Sex" a lot as well as "The Robot with Human Hair pt. II 1/2" but that's like... it.
DBM2 had some winners for me. Blue Dream, Elder Goose (catchy and so fun to play), Privilously Poncheezied (i don't know why that song gets no love - the guitar work in the beginning is so pretty) and Heat Seeking Ghost of Sex are all tracks I go back to when I'm on a Jonny kick. The rest are super forgettable imo. I can listen to any other DGD album all the way through and love every second but not that one.
I love Privilously Poncheezied, but I think lots dislike that part where there's loads of effects on Jon's voice (with it bouncing left to right in the mix etc.). Song is some of the best guitar work Will's done IMO and super fun to play along with. Also, the part between 1:45 and 2:30 is one of my fav DGD sections ever! Edit: Damn, the end riff is quality too! Pretty much my fav song on the album along with 'Perfect' lol.