Coheed & Cambria Band • Page 111

I like SSTB is 3rd from the bottom, with only YOTBR and TCBTS behind it for the reasons you bring up.

 

if you didn’t remove it from the context of “doesn’t hold up as well as some of their other stuff” it wouldn’t look so bad. obviously SSTB holds up. obviously clarity holds up. obviously full collapse holds up. in all those cases I would take the vast majority (if not all for Thursday) of the albums that came after them even to this day. just how I feel about it you can cancel me all you want. go ahead and cancel me that’s just my opinion if you don’t like it you can go right ahead and just cancel me for it. I don’t care if I get cancelled for saying those bands had better albums after their first breakout cult classic that’s just my opinion

 

You heard the man. CANCEL THEM!

 

SSTB starts strong but the last handful of songs just don't hold up to the first half.

 

I’m sorry I’m completely tik tok brained there’s this guy who goes into game lobbies and says you can just go ahead and cancel me for that for the dumbest shit and I die every time I see it. Anyway.

 

Didn't know the exact reference but I did think it was hilarious.

 

You're toast, buddy! Burnt, blackened, ashy TOAST.

 

SSTB rules, but I get why someone would have it lower in their rankings. It’s extremely front-heavy and I do think they went on to do bigger and better things

 

Calling SSTB front-heavy is so wack to me when Junesong and Neverender are right there

 

33 and Neverender are the only songs in the back half that I love and I’d still take three of the first five songs on the album over them

 

Neverender is goated

 

Good Apollo 1
In Keeping Secrets
Vaxis II
Color Before The Sun
YOTBR
Good Apollo 2
SSTB
Ascension
Descension
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Vaxis 1


Vaxis 1 makes me physically angry.

Honestly, I don't know how to rank Color, Rainbow, Apollo 2, SSTB, Asc, Des.........

 

vaxis I is like....goated coheed. insane

 

I’ll probably get to a ranking eventually but Vaxis II is my favorite since No World for Tomorrow

 

This thread is up there for me for most hot takes on this site.

 

I will ride with you here.

 

I’ve been listening these guys a lot lately after all this ranking talk.

I’ve always really struggled to rank Coheed’s albums. I know Good Apollo 1 is my favorite. But beyond that it always got murky.

I’m going to try to rectify that with some serious listening.

I’ll leave this as a placeholder, but so far I know this:

From Fear Through the Eyes of Madness

Afterman
In Keeping Secrets

No World for Tomorrow
Vaxis 1
Second Stage Turbine

Year of the Black Rainbow

Still too early for me to confidently rank Vaxis II.

 

Color Before The Sun is last, that's all I know.

 

and it’s still pretty good

 

I thought this said least favorite and had a heart attack. I’d agree if not for Vaxis I. Both Vaxis albums are in the top half of my rankings easy. Can’t wait for the next part.

 

what the fuck is your problem

 

two weeks later after listening to tons of Vaxis II I’d put it above good Apollo now

 

I may have exaggerated a bit. I really just never liked that record that much. And it's wild to me too because I should like it.

 

I’m gonna hire a private spec ops team to come extract you and put you in a torture chamber where you’re forced to listen to it