Coheed and Cambria - Vaxis - Act I: The Unheavenly Creatures (October 5, 2018) Album • Page 18

color before the sun is a top 4 one for me

 

goddamn I loved the Afterman albums. No World For Tomorrow was decent but all my love for them died after that album. Ascension pulled me right back in.

 

Can never say no to Coheed ranking

IKSOSE: 3
SSTB
GA1
Ascension
Decension
Black Rainbow
GA2
Color

 

GA1
IKS
SSTB
Decension
Ascension
GA2
TCBTS
Black Rainbow

 

IKS
SSTB
GA1
GA2

the sound of my dog farting


Decension/Ascension/TCBTS/BR (because i absolutely loathe all of these with the exception of a few songs)

 

i...i kinda wanna hear your dog fart now

 

this one

 

IKS
SSTB
GA:1
Afterman (Ascension and Decension)
TCBTS
GA2
Black Rainbow

Big drop off in my ranks after TCBTS. Coheed is my favorite band so I still love plenty of tracks off GA2 and Black Rainbow, but Josh's drumming on the other albums is such a big part of why I love them.

 

GAIBSIV
IKS
NWFT
Descension
Ascension
SSTB
TCBTS
YOTBR

That’s honestly hard because I do like TCBTS and I’ve gained a new found appreciation for YOTBR recently too. I guess the only slightly controversial thing is that I like NWFT more than most.

 

If you compare The Afterman albums with your dog farting then you should leave this thread

 

RT

 

i tried very hard to like the color before the sun. the songs do nothing for me for the most part

 

I enjoyed "Island" and "Here to Mars", but I can never see myself returning to them.

 

i think "island" is great tbh

 

I like most of the album but it took me awhile. I had to think of it in a different way than I do the rest of their work. It still feels like almost listening to a different band.

 

TCBTS is great pop rock outside of The Audience. That songs a mess.

 

That's basically the reason I couldn't get into it. Not a big pop rock fan.

 

Yeah TCBTS is the only one I could never get into, otherwise I like them all kind of equally.

I guess I would say IKS is prob my favorite, and (excluding TCBTS) Descension is my least.

 

Descension gets an automatic bump for me just for Gravity's Union alone. CCCCCCCAAAAAAaaaaaAAAAAAaaaaGGGGGGGEEDDDD

 

LAWWKEEED IN PURRPETchuAL MOWWWTIAWNNNOOHHHAWNNN

 

CAHVING ARGH WOOOOONDS WIIIIDE OOOHPEEEHHUN

 

BUT YOU LET THE WRONG ONE IIIIIINNNNNNnnnnnNNNNN

HA HA HA HA

 

stop

 

why

 

I was posting lyrics too, I just didn't say which song

carry on