In A Sweater Poorly Knit Genuinely expected this to walk this match up! This is fascinating to me. Fox’s Dream is the best song on Ten Stories but it isn’t in my top 10 of mewithoutYou songs overall! A big thank you to the amazing @bachna84 who has run a very engaging and fun bracket. I think you do it very well and I’ve enjoyed exploring my favourite band in this intentional way. Thank you.
I love Hayley’s vocals but the lyrics at the end feel more ‘story’ than ones I connect with emotionally. The first half is majestic though. Still prefer In A Sweater!
Current Totals: In A Sweater Poorly Knit - 10 Fox's Dream Of The Log Flume - 10 I’ll keep this round open until noon (Eastern Time) today.
That’s it, everyone! In A Sweater Poorly Knit has won it all! Final Totals: In A Sweater Poorly Knit - 11 Fox's Dream Of The Log Flume - 10 ———————— Thanks again to everyone for your participation - it’s been fun!
Not what I would’ve chosen, but I get it. This was fun and I’m glad I revisited their discography, especially the ones I rarely listen to like A—>B and Ten Stories. I’m also glad a lot of people revisited It’s All Crazy! and seem to have recognized how good it really is.
I guess in a sense Sweater is the quintessential mwY song. I don’t love it as much as a lot of others, but it’s very good. I would love to see this done with the National’s discography.