Bracket Thread for a Band Called The Maine Bracket • Page 32

Black butt
American Candy
Take What
Ho Ho Ho

 

Black Butterflies
American Candy
Take
Identify

 

The top half of the bracket is way more stacked than the bottom half (which includes the winners of the EP and cover rounds)!

Black Butterflies & Déjà Vu (This was surprisingly difficult! If I was voting solely on nostalgia, I would have voted for We All Roll Along, but I do think that overall I enjoy Black Butterflies & Deja Vu more. If nothing else, the final minute of the song gives it the edge for me)

American Candy (This may be the song that I want to win the champions bracket - I'm already dreading a potential matchup against Black Butterflies & Deja Vu next round)

Take What You Can Carry (I think that Steal My Sunshine is a great cover song, but I can't in good conscience vote for it over one of their original songs)

Identify (This was relatively easy for me - Ho Ho Hopefully is solid, but it has no business being in the final 4)

 

Black Butterflies & Déjà Vu
American Candy
Take What You Can Carry
Identify

 

Black Butterflies & Déjà Vu
American Candy
Take What You Can Carry
Identify

 

END OF ROUND 1 /// FINAL SCORES

We All Roll Along: 3
Black Butterflies & Déjà Vu: 10
----------
Don't Stop Now: 2
American Candy: 11
----------
Take What You Can Carry: 12
Steal My Sunshine: 1
----------
Identify: 11
Ho Ho Hopefully: 2

ROUND 2
2a) Black Butterflies & Déjà Vu vs. American Candy
2b) Take What You Can Carry vs. Identify

Go!

 

Damn, Take What You Can Carry and Identify do not belong here.

 

100% but, with that said:

Black Butterflies & Déjà Vu
Identify

An easy one for me. After this ends, we all should share which out of their discography deserved this round, and the winner.

 

Black Butterflies
Identify

 

Honest to god i could not be happier with this outcome these are exactly the songs I would pick for the top 4:

Black Butterflies (pretty easy choice)
Take What You Can Carry (slightly more difficult, but not that hard. Won’t be upset at all if Identify wins though)

 

American Candy
Identify

I give a leg up on Identify just because I think that interlude is cool as fuck. Love that 88 snake line too.

 

American candy
Identify

 

American Candy
Take

 

American Candy
Take What You Can Carry

 

Black Butterflies & Déjà Vu
Take What You Can Carry

 

Black Butterflies
Identify

 

Butterflies
Identify

 

American Candy (This was a very difficult decision! I expect the winner of this matchup to win the next round quite easily)

Identify (This was a pretty easy pick for me)

 

Black Butterflies and Deja Vu
Identify

 

Black Butterflies & Déjà Vu
Identify

 

CURRENT SCORES

American Candy: 5
Black Butterflies & Déjà Vu: 8
----------
Identify: 9
Take What You Can Carry: 4

 

American Candy
Take What You Can Carry

 

END OF ROUND 2 /// FINAL SCORES

American Candy: 6
Black Butterflies & Déjà Vu: 8
----------
Identify: 9
Take What You Can Carry: 5

Now to the finale!!!

FINAL ROUND
Black Butterflies & Déjà Vu vs. Identify

Go!

 

Identify! (Although, I can see how this may end).

 

Identify <\3