Basket Case Real tough, but have to go with Basket Case. First punk song I ever heard - my dad bought Dookie on cassette when it came out, so I was around 6 at the time and had it on while he was finishing up some work and I just remember hearing Basket Case for the first time and having that “first time I heard the Beatles” kind of moment with it.
Basket Case I don't usually participate in these, does the most popular song from every album usually win
It depends. Some bands have pretty strong singles and it reflects in the bracket results. For some bands, almost none of their singles made it to the finals.
Nimrod has the best non-single songs. I mean, The Grouch, Scattered, Worry Rock, King for a Day (a fan favorite, but still).
Final scores: When I Come Around - 15 Basket Case - 8 When I Come Around is the winner of Dookie! Stay tuned for the Insomniac bracket.
INSOMNIAC BRACKET Round 1: Stuck With Me Vs. Jaded Tight Wad Hill Vs. 86 No Pride Vs. Stuart and the Ave. Armatage Shanks Vs. Geek Stink Breath Panic Song Vs. Brain Stew Bab's Uvula Who? Vs. Brat
Not a big fan of these next two albums. Jaded Tight Wad Hill Stuart and the Ave. Geek Stink Breath Brain Stew Brat
Stuck with Me 86 Stuart and the Ave. Geek Stink Breath Brain Stew Brat I can barely understand a single word Billie sings on this record.
I'd chalk it up to single vs. non-single on a record that a lot of people don't seem to have any connection to for whatever reason (which is wack because this is one of GD's best records) Armatage is, like, clearly the better song though I'm with you
Personally, I’d chalk it up to people here thinking Geek is the better song, which I definitely do lol
Stuart is the song that deserves to win but probably won't oh well RIP This album is fantastic, and every time I listen to it it makes a case to be my favorite