What the hell, I'll keep it spicy by tying it back. I just have such strong memories listening to Nine In the Afternoon on repeat for like days when it first came out and just being so excited Panic! was coming back. The song really just makes me feel inexplicably happy, so I have to vote for it in the end. I think this has literally been my hardest bracket vote ever.
Current scores: When the Day Met the Night - 7 Nine in the Afternoon - 8 Nine in the Afternoon takes back the lead.
I love an underdog so I'm secretly rooting for When the Day Met the Night despite my Nine In the Afternoon vote, that way I can't possibly be upset either way
I’ll join the “When the Day Met the Night is the best song on Pretty. Odd.” squad. I think both (likely) winners of the first two albums are top notch. I feel like my opinions about Vices & Virtues are going to differ significantly from everyone else though.
Final scores: When the Day Met the Night - 11 Nine in the Afternoon - 9 We have a winner! When the Day Met the Night is declared champion of Pretty. Odd. I will create the V&V bracket and will be back in a moment.
VICES & VIRTUES BRACKET Round 1: 1) The Calendar Vs. Trade Mistakes 2) Nearly Witches (Ever Since We Met...) Vs. Sarah Smiles Round 2: Ready to Go (Get Me Out of My Mind) Vs Winner of 1) Memories Vs. Hurricane The Ballad of Mona Lisa Vs. Winner of 2) Let's Kill Tonight Vs. Always Round 1 starts now!
The Calendar Nearly Witches (Ever Since We Met...) Easy choices, these two are both some of my favorites on the album.