Boy Landing Mary Killing Not sure if I'd say these are my 4 favorite Bayside songs, but I'd say they're all top 10 at least. Not bad for one of these brackets
Boy - 3 The Whitest Lie - 2 Masterpiece - 1 Landing Feet First - 4 Blame it on Bad Luck - 3 Mary - 2 Killing Time - 5 Winter - 0
NOW SHIT GETS INTERESTING! Boy- This one was tough because Boy isn't my favorite song on Shudder (RIP The Ghost of Saint Valentine) while The Whitest Lie is my favorite song on Cult. However, head to head, I enjoy Boy more overall. Landing Feet First- Masterpiece goes SO HARD, but at this point in my life I enjoy a song like Landing Feet First much more. One of my favorite love songs in music. Mary- The bridge of Blame it on Bad Luck had my favorite Bayside lyrics ever. I'm a sucker for lyrics about nostalgia. This was the toughest matchup to pick, but I am going with Mary. Killing Time- It pains me to vote against Winter. Killing Time is just too huge to be ignored.
Boy - 6 The Whitest Lie - 3 Masterpiece - 1 Landing Feet First - 8 Blame it on Bad Luck - 3 Mary - 6 Killing Time - 8 Winter - 1
Boy (This was pretty easy for me since Boy is one of my favorite overall Bayside songs. The best part of The Whitest Lie is its outro, but I think Boy's outro is better) Landing Feet First (This one is also pretty easy for me since Landing Feet First is another one of my favorite overall Bayside songs. Next round could potentially be very difficult for me!) Blame it on Bad Luck (Not quite as easy as the first two matchups, but still fairly straightforward. I know a lot of people are burnt out on Blame it on Bad Luck, which is fair, but I think it's the better of the two songs) Killing Time (Winter is great, but Killing Time has pretty much everything I want from a Bayside song)
Boy - 10 The Whitest Lie - 3 Masterpiece - 2 Landing Feet First - 11 Blame it on Bad Luck - 6 Mary - 7 Killing Time - 12 Winter - 1 We’re essentially playing for one matchup at this point.