Winter (I prefer Indiana musically, but I have to go with Winter purely from a lyrical and emotional standpoint) Monster (This was my first time hearing either of these - I’ll give this the edge) Battle Scars (It Don’t Exist is a good song, but I typically prefer their non-acoustic songs) You’ve Already Been (My favorite b-side/bonus track of theirs)
Indiana - 0 Winter - 4 Don’t Come Easy - 1 Monster - 3 Battle Scars - 2 It Don’t Exist - 2 Paternal Reversal - 1 You’ve Already Been - 3
Indiana vs. Winter We all know why this song is amazing. Don’t Come Easy vs. Monster No real reason here. Battle Scars vs. It Don’t Exist If only this song existed earlier. I wish it could have been played at my wedding. Paternal Reversal vs. You’ve Already Been Dang, this is a tough one. They're both songs that get played just as often as any other Bayside song.
Winter Easy Exist Reversal Is there a scenario where Winter doesn’t win this round? No. The answer is no.
Winter Hmmm a coin flip for me, go with Don't Come Easy, only because I'm more familiar with it Battle scars Paternal
Indiana - 0 Winter - 8 Don’t Come Easy - 4 Monster - 4 Battle Scars - 3 It Don’t Exist - 5 Paternal Reversal - 4 You’ve Already Been - 4
This is very cool. I'm new to this whole thing.....was Loveless Wrists up for anything? That was the first bayside song I heard
Glad you’re enjoying it! Unfortunately, it was not. We decided not to include any of the EPs. I do like Loveless Wrists though!
I have to work until 6pm EST tomorrow, so I’ll probably just leave this round open until then, barring any drastic swings in the voting. Won’t have any time to set up the next round at work.
Winter Monster (not sure I'd ever heard this one before, but wow it's awesome) It Don't Exist You've Already Been
Winter absolutely crushes me for personal reasons and ill never be able to listen to that song without tearing up but i love it so much
Final scores: Indiana - 0 Winter - 15 Don’t Come Easy - 9 Monster - 6 Battle Scars - 3 It Don’t Exist - 12 Paternal Reversal - 6 You’ve Already Been - 9