This bracket is going to get all sorts of weird when we get to the miscellaneous portion and songs from the Long Stories Short EP are up against the mature acoustic stuff like "Winter" and "It Don't Exist." Also, are covers going to be considered? "Megan" is one of the more popular songs Bayside does, and they released an entire covers EP a few years back.
For real. I think I’m going to include the covers, b-sides, one offs, etc all in one big bracket at the end. That’s the plan for now anyway.
Okay, that’s all for round 2. Moving on... Guardrail vs. Masterpiece Alcohol and Alter Boys vs. Just Enough to Love You
RIP Michelangelo. Gone too soon (although I can't imagine I would've voted for it over whatever wins the next albums anyway). For this round: Masterpiece Alcohol
I don't know if I can write anything that'll help me choose between these songs. I'll just go with the ones that have been stuck in my head the most over the past couple of days. Guardrail vs. Masterpiece Alcohol and Alter Boys vs. Just Enough to Love You
Guardrail Just Enough to Love You Sorta surprised Guardrail is getting crushed rn, it's probably my favorite on this album.
Guardrail is good, but I like the lyrics in masterpiece quite a bit more, which pushes it over for me Similarly, I didn’t realize just enough was so well loved. Probably my least favorite on the album haha
Guardrail vs. Masterpiece Sticking with that intro as long as I can. It probably says something that I have not voted for Masterpiece once, yet I have absolutely no issue with it making it to the final. Great song for sure. Alcohol and Alter Boys vs. Just Enough to Love You Guess I'm not as big of a fan of Just Enough to Love You as everyone else. I like it, don't get me wrong, but I'd say it's near the bottom of my album rankings for sure. Alcohol and Altar Boys is one of my favorites, so it gets my vote.