Best of Foo (Foo Fighters bracket) Bracket • Page 3

I just recently fell in love with How I Miss You. I think it’s one of the best songs Dave has written.

 

Current scores:

Alone + Easy Target - 8
Floaty - 1

X-Static - 5
Weenie Beenie - 4

Oh, George - 5
Podunk - 4

Good Grief - 5
For All The Cows - 4

How I Miss You - 2
Big Me - 7

Wattershed - 1
This Is a Call - 8

I'll Stick Around - 6
Exhausted - 3

 

Good grief, For all the Cows is losing?

 

I see what you did there.

 

-Alone + Easy Target

-Static X (YEAH, YA PUSH IT! So I grabbed my shovel. RIP)

-Oh, George

-Good Grief

-Big Me

-This Is A Call

-Exhausted

 

I love For all the Cows, but I guess it's a MOOt point.

 

I haven't notched enough listens over the past 15 years to vote in all the matchups, but it's a goddamn travesty to see Floaty blown out

 

Alone+Easy Target
X-Static
Podunk
Good Grief
How I Miss You
This Is A Call
Exhausted (Easily the toughest matchup this round. both songs are super good.)

 

I do really like Floaty, but Alone+Easy Target is a top 3 song on this album for me.

 

A+ET is solid, but the chorus always felt like a letdown after the great intro/verses

 

Im rooting so hard for Exhausted cause for me thats in my Top 5 FF songs.

 

Alone + Easy Target

Weenie Beenie

Podunk (I think this is the first time I've ever heard this song)

For All The Cows

Big Me

This Is a Call (This matchup sucks - I really do love Wattershed)

I'll Stick Around (Tough one! I'd be happy with either song advancing here)

 

Current scores:

Alone + Easy Target - 11
Floaty - 1

X-Static - 7
Weenie Beenie - 5

Oh, George - 6
Podunk - 6

Good Grief - 7
For All The Cows - 5

How I Miss You - 3
Big Me - 9

Wattershed - 1
This Is a Call - 11

I'll Stick Around - 7
Exhausted - 5

 

It's pretty calm compared to the Paramore bracket!

 

Maybe everyone is...Exhausted.

 

more people will likely join in for TCATS and TINLTL, though i do think this is a pretty solid debut.

 

Yes! Its so good!

It definitely has some excellent tracks on it, if only the production was better.

 

1) Alone + Easy Target

2) Weenie Beenie

3) Oh, George

4) For All The Cows

5) Big Me

6) This Is a Call

7) Exhausted

 

It really hurt me to vote against Weenie Beenie but I just love the vibe of X-Static

 

First round is over! Final scores:

Alone + Easy Target - 12
Floaty - 1

X-Static - 7
Weenie Beenie - 6

Oh, George - 7
Podunk - 6

Good Grief - 7
For All The Cows - 6

How I Miss You - 3
Big Me - 10

Wattershed - 1
This Is a Call - 12

I'll Stick Around - 7
Exhausted - 6


Round 2:

Winnebago Vs. Alone + Easy Target

X-Static Vs. Oh, George

Good Grief Vs. Big Me

This Is a Call Vs. I'll Stick Around

 

Floaty (never been a big fan of Alone + Easy Target)
Weenie Beenie
Podunk (never knew this song but wish I did).
Good Grief
Big Me
This is a Call
I’ll Stick Around

 

Whoops... I’d have pushed a few, too. My bad...

 

Well to be fair, I would have voted Oh, George and X-Static to break the ties so it actually wouldn't have changed anything. You can vote on Round 2 though!

 

Alone + Easy Target
X- Static
Good Grief
I'll Stick Around

 

Phew! I didn’t need that cross.

Oh, George vs X-Static is tough. On one hand I feel like X-Static would have been a Nirvana song, but the gazey vocals should escalate to go with the gnarly drumming; On the other, Oh George is Serve the Servant’s less impressive little brother.

Winnebago
X-Static
Big Me
I’ll Stick Around