Best of Foo (Foo Fighters bracket) Bracket • Page 15

Pretty much all of my top 10 are from those three albums:

Bridge Burning, Walk, Let It Die, Best of You, No Way Back, Dear Rosemary, Erase/Replace, The Pretender, Rope

 

Low

 

Erase/Replace 4 life

 

Wasting Light is easily one of their most consistent and well made records and one of the best straightforward rock records to come out this decade (Also the Bob Mould feature is awesome). I personally find that In Your Honor suffers from being bloated and they didn't need to put out a double album. Part of it is that I've never been a big fan of the acoustic half. Just not what I'm looking for from these guys. Echoes is pretty cool overall but I find it pretty front heavy from what I remember since last listening to it (Its been a while).

 

You're forgetting D.O.A, Resolve, and One Of These Days.

 

I didn't forget! Those songs rock, but aren't in my top 10. Gotta leave room for Everlong and Breakout!

 

you might want to recount ;)

 

Nope, that would require me to remove one of those songs and I can't do it. I'll just live forever in ignorant bliss

 

The fact that they don’t play DOA live anymore makes me so frustrated.

 

With the number of votes we usually get, Low ain't coming back from this. Final scores:

Low - 3
All My Life - 8

In Your Honor Disc 1 incoming.

 

FOO FIGHTERS FACE OFF:

IN YOUR HONOR (DISC 1)

-----

Round 1


No Way Back Vs. End Over End

The Deepest Blues Are Black Vs. Hell

The Sign Vs. DOA


Round 1 starts now!

 

End Over End
Deepest
DOA

 

No Way Back
Deepest
DOA

 

No Way Back
The Deepest Blues Are Black
DOA

 

End Over End
The Deepest Blues Are Black
DOA

 

-No Way Back

-The Deepest Blues Are Black

-DOA

 

No Way Back
Deepest Blues
DOA

 

No Way Back
Deepest Blues
DOA

 

I feel like this round will be a total shutout

 

End over End (WAY better than No Way Back)
Hell
DOA

Just fast forward this entire album because Best of You is obviously sweeping.

 

No Way Back (the only difficult matchup here)
The Deepest Blues Are Black
DOA

 

My hot take for this album: Best Of You is among the bottom 2 or 3 songs for me.

 

That take may burn down this website

 

End Over End
Deepest Blues Are Black
DOA


End Over End is so underrated. It’s their last great album closer.