Best of Foo (Foo Fighters bracket) Bracket • Page 12

FOO FIGHTERS FACE OFF:

ONE BY ONE

-----

Round 1


Have It All Vs. Walking a Line

Halo Vs. Low

Overdrive Vs. Come Back

Disenchanted Lullaby Vs. Tired of You


Round 1 starts now!

 

Have it All
Halo
Come Back
Tired of You

Come Back and Tired of You are two of my favorite FF songs

 

Walking a Line
Low
Come Back
Disenchanted Lullaby (this was the toughest)

 

Times Like These is my favorite FF song so I'm totally rooting for it.

 

Have It All
Low ( I actually like Halo but this is a top song)
Come Back
Disenchanted Lullaby (so underrated)

 

Have It All
Halo
Come Back
Disenchanted Lullaby

All these years I thought Walking a Line was a cover. This morning I found out I was wrong

 

I need to give this a listen later today - it’s been ages since I listened in full

 

Have It All
Low
Come Back
Disenchanted Lullaby

 

Have It All
Low
Come Back
DisenchantedLullaby

 

No one voting for Tired of You is absolute blasphemy

 

It's my least favorite song on the album haha

 

It was very tough. I love both of those songs. And I love Brian May’s guitar swells on Tired of You.

 

I need to listen to the album through before I do this haha
Damn the intro to All My Life gets me hype.

 

The foos really know their way around album openers. Almost all of them start out strong.

 

Have It All
Low
Come Back
Tired of You <-Difficult

 

Walking a Line
Low
Come Back
Disenchanted Lullaby

I don’t dislike this album, but it’s certainly one of my least revisited of theirs.

 

Have It All
Low
Come Back
Tired of You

All My Life, Times Like These, Tired of You and Come Back are all in my top tier Foo songs

 

Have It All
Halo
Come Back
Disenchanted Lullaby

I’m glad I’m not the only one that thinks Tired of You is the weakest song on the album. Come Back is incredibly underrated, but Halo is criminally underrated.

 

The first 4 songs are great, which is generally accepted as truth, but Disenchanted Lullaby, Halo, and Come Back are all great too I think and def underrated.

Overall I don't think One By One is as bad as people say it is, but the few songs (Tired Of you, Overdrive, Burn Away) that I would consider not great drag it down a bit.

 

I also used to like Lonely As You more but after hearing the demo version of that song which is better I've soured on it a little bit haha.

 

Have It All

Low

Overdrive

Disenchanted Lullaby

 

Final scores:

Have It All - 9
Walking a Line - 2

Halo - 3
Low - 8

Overdrive - 1
Come Back - 10

Disenchanted Lullaby - 8
Tired of You - 3


Next Round:

Lonely As You Vs. Have It All

Burn Away Vs. Low

All My Life Vs. Come Back

Times Like These Vs. Disenchanted Lullaby

 

Have It All
Low
All My Life
Disenchanted Lullaby

The first 2 were easy. The Last 2 were very difficult.

 

Have It All
Burn Away (never been a big fan of Low)
All My Life
Times Like These

 

Have It All
Low
All My Life
Times Like These