Bad Opinions II • Page 15

Weekend Nachos has five classic albums between Torture, Unforgivable, Worthless, Still, and Apology.

 

Radiohead has released af least 5 classic albums in the bends, ok computer, kid a, hail to the thief, and in rainbows. I think thrice released 5 classics in a row with the illusion of safety, the artist in the ambulance, vheissu, the alchemy index, and beggars even though technically the alchemy index is considered four eps

 

It really depends what parameters you put on it, because some artists are just SO big that they have, for lack of better words, haters... Like Taylor Swift has multiple stone cold classics, more people in the planet than any other artist world agree, but the stuck up music nerds might not agree so she doesn't get to fit it

 

I don’t think Taylor Swift has 5 in a row

 

That's kinda what I'm getting at though, I think that an insane number of people would agree Fearless through reputation world count, but they are the kind of fans of music that get discounted as having an opinion here

 

I am and have been a Taylor Swift fan for about 15 years. Reputation is a flawed album, even if I am giving a little bit of grace to call Fearless a “classic”

 

rep forever

 

I'd say arguably St Vincent and Sufjan would probably be the closest

 

Red, 1989, folklore are the ones I think are undeniably considered classics from music fans at large

 

I think I’ve heard one good St. Vincent song

 

Joanna Newsom needs one more release and shes in there

 

I think this is the important question to ask, and it takes a whole lot of albums/artists off the table.

 

Uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh









?

 

The one in the bear this season. Kinda find her annoying

 

bon iver comes close but I think i,i is easily his worst and not up to the level of the other 4

 

What have you heard, if you even know? She has more than a few undeniable tracks off each album.

 

These are less “classics” in a traditional way, but more for myself and my music taste:

Definite:
- Copeland (If you’re a BMT fan, then you can get 6)
- BN (Scandal Noted)
- From Indian Lakes (The first album was big for me at the time, but I don’t revisit it as much now)
Anberlin (NTFP onward. NS is influential and was what got me into the band, even if I don’t return to it now)
- 1975 (Every album has essential and classic songs, but idk if every album itself is a classic)

Maybe’s:
- The Antlers (Easy in if you count Peter’s solo album or the single collection, but they’re probably drop another fantastic album in October, so they’ll join in eventually lol)
- Pinegrove (Can we count the big album of all the EP’s?)
-Noah Gunderson (Scandal Noted)
- David Bazan / Pedro have just so much good music, but I’m still getting into it and can’t say for sure now lol.
- Kevin Devine

 

No clue. I did not like the Daddy album

 

Yeah me either, it's very bad. You should try Masseduction if you liked Fast Slow Disco.... It's not everyone's favorite, but it's my favorite and the least uhh annoying?? Haha

 

I feel like Sly has 2. Maybe 3? Curious what you put in there.

The others 100% agree.

 

Talking Book to Hotter Than July, 5 in a row easy

 

I will forever regret missing them. One day hopefully...

 

We really have different understandings of the word classic

 

classic has been warped on the internet from being one of the best albums ever to being any album that’s pretty good

 

Not to be rude, but who cares? This is a subjective discussion anyway, is this really something worth policing?