It's funny, I don't feel like it's an awful take, but it's a weird one coming from someone who seemingly only became disillusioned with Reflektor. It's kind of how I've felt about them since The Suburbs. "Assumption that big = epic" has been my complaint with them for 2 albums now. "an urgency they’ve often lost sight of while pursuing the ill-conceived notion of Very Important Dance Rock." <perfect description There are good songs on every album, so I don't hate them or anything, but deliberate bloat was only a strength on Funeral, imo.
I'd venture to say I am still a pretty big fan of Acade Fire but the excitement I felt leading into Neon Bible then The Suburbs and even Refelktor just isn't there for me this time around. I never loved the last album (save for a few tracks) and the single really isn't getting me that excited. I will still be listening to the album with an open mind and open ears the second it comes out. And hopefully they'll add another leg to the tour so I can see them. I caught three shows on the last full USA tour and all where fantastic.
I don't think there's a second of filler on Funeral. Like I've stated before, it took me years to get into this band but I'm borderline obsessed with Funeral now. Neighborhood #4 is a perfect song.
Funeral has to be somewhere in my top ten albums for the aughts interestingly though Neon Bible has what I think is their best song, My Body Is a Cage
Honestly all 4 are tied for me. Orpheus and Eurydice are what really elevate Reflektor for me , the rest is solid, but those two...
I think each of their first three albums are just perfect. Wouldn't change a thing about them. First half of Reflektor is a mixed bag, second half is some of their absolute best stuff.
The Suburbs is their masterpiece IMO, but Funeral and Neon Bible are great in their own right. Reflektor has some of their best songs on it but too much filler
I'd rank their albums in order of release. I think each one is a little less than the one before it. Funeral is perfect. Neon Bible is nearly perfect and oddly underrated, it's one flaw is it has some minor tracking issues (the first 3 tracks have an odd flow and I agree with P4K that "No Cars Go" should be the closer and "My Body is a Cage" feels tacked on), The Suburbs is a little bloated but still great. Reflektor sounds like it's made by a great band but I just think it's a good not great record.("Here Comes the Night Time", is a top 10 AF song though, they got that one right)
I love the Funeral and Neon Bible, like The Suburbs and Reflektor. I think both Reflektor and The Suburbs have a fair amount of bloat but the highs on Reflektor are generally higher than Suburbs for me outside of Sprawl II.
Tracklist, rumored yesterday then confirmed today via anagrams from the Everything Now Twitter: 1. Everything Now (Slow) 2. Everything Now 3. Signs of Life 4. Creature Comfort 5. Peter Pan 6. Chemistry 7. Infinite Content 8. Infinite Content (Slow) 9. Electric Blue 10. Good God Damn 11. Put Your Money on Me 12. We Don't Deserve Love 13. Everything Now (Continued)
What a setlist they played tonight. SETLIST Wake Up Everything Now Haiti Here Comes The Night Time No Cars Go Intervention Neon Bible The Suburbs (with continued outro) In The Backseat Ready To Start Sprawl II (Mountains Beyond Mountains) Reflektor Afterlife We Exist (I Give You Power intro) Creature Comfort Neighbourhood #3 (Power Out) Rebellion (Lies) ENCORE Windowsill
always surprised when they don't play My Body Is A Cage, they didn't play it when I saw them either Ready to Start Neighborhood #2 (Laika) No Cars Go Haiti Empty Room The Suburbs Crown of Love Rococo Intervention We Used to Wait Neighborhood #3 (Power Out) Rebellion (Lies) Month of May Keep the Car Running Encore: Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels) Sprawl II (Mountains Beyond Mountains) Wake Up
I've never seen Arcade Fire live before, but if I ever got the chance - My Body Is A Cage is the track I would want to see the most.
I feel like they don't play it often, but they should. Most people I know, myself included, got into Arcade Fire through that song. I don't know if it's just a coincidence, but regardless it seems like it's a fan favorite.
So uh...I adore this band and they've given me two of the best shows I've seen in my life. But HOLY SHIT tickets in the 100's section of Madison Square Garden $116? That is ABSURD.
They opened with "My Body Is a Cage" when I saw them play Toronto on the Reflektor tour. It was the song I was hoping they would play but didn't expect them to. Now I can die happy.
I've never been a monster fan of Arcade Fire but I've casually followed them since Funeral and this song is pretty par for the course. Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels) Neighborhood #3 (Power Out) Rebellion (Lies) Keep the Car Running Sprawl II (Mountains Upon Mountains) They've lost a little bit of their spastic delivery over the years but this new song carries their disco-pop tradition well
Eh...not compared to some Other arena shows. Kendrick would be around 150, a big pop star like Katy perry would probably be 200.